The New Bipolar World and One-Dimensional Politics
Updated Editorial Commentary By: Dr. J. P. Hubert
A strange but remarkable phenomenon now exists in the realm of social discourse. Virtually all concepts which bear upon public policy are presented to the masses as essentially, a choice between two polar opposites. For example, there is the liberal vs. conservative, right vs. left, Republican vs. Democratic views, etc., as if there are no other frames of reference by which one might consider important issues of the day. This needless to say establishes a completely contrived and false dichotomy. It is as if a very attenuated/ distorting prism or lens has been placed before our collective minds eye.
Increasingly, society seems to have embraced the binary gestalt writ-large. For example, the only format which seems to be universally embraced by the corporate (especially television and radio) media when airing debate with respect to an issue of public policy is to arbitrarily select two individuals from opposite sides of the political spectrum. Each is then allowed to spew forth their respective “talking points” in an exchange where rhetorical flourish and rank sophistry is allowed to pass for meaningful elucidation of opinion/position(s). Sober analysis and rational discussion through thoughtful and respectful interchange of ideas is simply never forthcoming.
Rather than a situation where so-called experts are asked to come reason together, what one routinely witnesses is largely impolite jousting between two individuals each of whom function as either paid or unpaid advocates for their respective positions—presumably neither would be invited back again were they to attempt anything else. It is inconceivable that one could arrive at the truth through the employment of this commonly utilized (largely entertainment oriented) vehicle/tactic.
What it resembles is something akin to a sporting event where two teams compete in a game/contest until one prevails. The viewing public is expected to enthusiastically support one or the other of the two opponents since their positions are not only (presumably) mutually exclusive but supposedly representative of the entire universe of possibilities rather than artificially truncated ones. The entire situation would be laughable if it were not so serious.
The One-Dimensional Nature of American Politics
Many have noticed the absurdity of contemporary politics where all questions of public policy are presented as if they were located upon a one-dimensional axis e.g. the “X” axis for illustrative purposes. Under this rubric there is no possibility that any issue could somehow be located on any other axis of dimension, “Y” or “Z” for example. This means that in a figurative sense, all issues lack the depth affored by “3” dimensional space. In fact the current situation is even worse than that of the so-called “flat-lander’s” who according to a popular mind experiment inhabit only a flat plane distributed along the "X" and "Y" axes. In contradistinction to human beings who physically inhabit “3” dimensions of space, the flat-lander’s inhabit only 2, e.g. length and width. It is not difficult to imagine how much more limited would be the perception of beings who despite being capable of mathematically theorizing the existence of a third dimension would be unable to actually experience it utilizing sense data. This is by analogy the situation we find ourselves in with respect to one-dimensional contemporary politics. We are disadvantaged by virtue of being limited to only one horizontal(X- axis) dimension which is metaphorically analagous to a finite bounded line rather than a "2" dimensional plane or "3" dimensional object. This severely attenuated construct is simply incapable of serving as a platform on which to discuss "3" dimensional reality.
The ruling oligarchical Regime tells us that all issues of public policy are somehow distributed along a one dimensional line which rather than being a circle is actually straight, bounded on each end artificially by the radical left and the radical right with virtually limitless points in-between. The truly strange thing about this one dimensional line is that it admits of only one differentiating characteristic that is, the amount of control or influence the government is entitled to exercise over the populace.
For example, the liberal left tends to favor minimal control over personal sexual behavior while the conservative right claims to desire the opposite. Yet the conservative right favors minimal control over the finances of corporations and individuals while the liberal left demands serious regulation on the part of the government over the finances of both corporations and individuals. The only constant is the issue of the amount of “governmental control” over the population not whether there is a universally liberal or conservative absolute which is singularly to be associated with a given party. In that sense, the terms liberal and conservative have no meaning. They simply do not contain much informational content. As such each person is forced to memorize what each political party finds currently fashionable on any given issue of public policy.
It should be self evident that the major political parties are made up of various “interest groups” each of which have preferences. It is the prospective interest groups that determine what each political party espouses and nothing more. To say one is a liberal or a conservative for example is not to say anything which can be universalized. For example, Conservatives do not wish to “conserve” any more than liberals do. Liberals are no more interested in minimal governmental control over individuals than are conservatives. They each have their respective issues (albeit different ones) about which they demand minimal governmental interference and vice-versa.
It should be unnecessary to purport that the two-party political system as it currently exists in the United States is a kind of charade where various power-centers participate in a one-dimensional political exercise designed to advance the desires of the respective interest groups which make up each political party. The truth is that it is not a single line bounded artificially on each end by the radical left and right, but a cone, the bottom of which is actually a circle upon which all of the disparate interest groups are distributed. The top of the cone represents the oligarchical elite also known as the controlling "Regime" which ultimately determines the extent of permissible discourse (along the circle) through a kind of opposing (Hegelian) dialectic.
Enter Hegel
The above enumerated phenomenon has helped create a permanent societal split or division that--while varying to a minor degree on a percentage basis from time to time--never really comes to grip with the essence or nature of any issue/problem. Perhaps an explanation for this unfortunate dilemma is that an apparent Hegelian dialectic (thesis, antithesis, and synthesis) has become the chosen mechanism by which our oligarchical elites attempt to program/mold mass opinion. Not only does this technique seriously limit the bounds of acceptable public discourse, it implies that all issues of social import are ultimately to be resolved on the basis of a “rough and tumble” contest of wills and sophistic verbiage rather than any real sense of absolute truth(s) which might serve as guiding principles. This no doubt is a legacy of the Enlightenment.
The crucial point is that the acceptable boundary for public discussion is artificially circumscribed by the ruling elites in such a way as to control outcomes both at the level of topic selection and subsequent debate parameters and verbal/written interaction. A good example of this phenomenon is the two-ring circus which transpires every four years in which the public is treated to the spectacle of appearing to select from a large field of candidates—two individuals to vie for President of the United States. In reality, the most interesting and controversial candidates are eliminated fairly early such that the two final candidates actually differ quite minimally in terms of domestic and foreign policy preferences. Judging by the evidence, this is by design of the ruling class. In the most recent presidential election, U.S. citizens were given the choice between two seemingly different individuals, one apparently traditional (Mc Cain) the other more exotic representing “change” (Obama)--who Americans presumably preferred. Yet, both were clearly funded by and beholden to the elite power brokers whose interests would be served irrespective of which one prevailed.
It is noteworthy that after only 19 months in office, President Obama has largely followed the Bush/Cheney foreign and domestic (especially economic) policies despite campaigning vociferously against them. There is no evidence that Mr. Obama intends to dismantle the American empire or significantly reduce US militarism. There is nothing to establish that he has repudiated the Bush Doctrine of preventive war. In fact he has authorized offensive US military (armed drones) attacks in Pakistan and Afghanistan which have killed innocent non-combatants and most disturbingly announced a policy of preventive detention of “terrorists.” The latter immoral and illegal policy is more aggressive than what the Bush/Cheney administration attempted in that regard.
More recently the Obama administration has claimed the power to execute American citizens within the borders of the United States on only the suspicion of being tied to terrorism. This means that Americans may be summarily executed without trial at the direction of the President, a truly atrocious development and really the sine qua non of a Nazi police state. For the remainder of this article it may be helpful for the reader to keep a mental picture of the “cone” described above in the forefront of one’s mind.
Abandonment of Reality, Reason
In reality, there are very few issues of public policy which can be adequately considered through the prism of a binary lens--even though doing so has become the new norm--understood as the one-dimensional political construct outlined above. Similarly the related notion that all social/political questions must have either a yes or no answer flies in the face of reality—if true all “what” questions or those having to do with the nature or being of things would be eliminated— an unfortunate but foreseeable effect of the post-Enlightenment abandonment of metaphysics. The result is an artificial oversimplification which does not mirror reality but instead serves as a rhetorical devise by which a proponent of one particular view attempts to dis-intellectually “score points” or in contemporary parlance “spin” the target audience.
Integral to construction of the bipolar worldview is the need to carefully narrow the formulation of any potential issue or premise. For example, one is either for or against gay “marriage” for or against enhanced interrogation (torture), in favor of or against “pre-emptive” war (when what is really meant is preventive war). All are vacuous notions without a careful articulation of what is actually meant by these terms. Once adequately defined that is, with precision, it is sometimes but not always possible to take a pro or con position with respect to some of the so-called issues of the day. The Western legal system now steeped in legal positivism (pragmatism) and based as it is in a binary adversarial process clearly contributes to this phenomenon as well.
Constant Change and Lack of Universals
A related trend is the completely ad-hoc division that has occurred over what is considered a liberal vs.: conservative view with respect to a given issue. For example, strict literal interpretations of each term (liberal/conservative) yield entirely different conclusions than can be had from a review of commonly understood usages of the terms. In other words, the monikers liberal and conservative have no fixed or foundational referent and are constantly subject to alteration based on the changing nature of various interest groups that comprise their political bases from time to time. This leads to incompatible contradictions with regard to the policies of self-described members of each group.
It is noteworthy that traditional Paleoconservatives eschew foreign wars of conquest and oppose so-called pre-emptive (preventive) wars. Neoconservatives enthusiastically support both. Which view should be thought to characterize the conservative position? In reality it is a matter of opinion only. Historically, Neoconservatism is clearly the aberration. The change presumably reflects the result of an internal political power struggle rather than a natural (ideological) evolution among adherents of conservatism.
Theoretically, conservatives (in the sense of preserving the status quo) should favor the continuation of whatever has gone before. If historically the United States engaged in defensive war only--than preventive war would be incompatible with conservatism and vice-versa. By analogy if abortion has become the legal norm, after decades, the conservative view should be pro-abortion. Obviously, the terms are not meant to be taken literally yet it becomes clear that there really is an ad-hoc and arbitrary nature to what is considered liberal and conservative from time to time. Neither term is based on a stable worldview (epistemology, metaphysics and moral philosophy).
Similar contradictions have occurred with respect to the policy positions held by proponents of liberalism (now referred to as adherents of progressive politics—one assumes the change in name was made ostensibly for perceived commercial advantage). Prior to 1973, liberals as defined by the Democratic Party held--along with conservatives as put forth by the Republican Party--that abortion on demand was immoral (the prevailing moral philosophy at the time was still heavily influenced by the Judeo-Christian Ethic) and should be kept illegal as a matter of public policy or at least left to the states to regulate. As a significant percentage of the Democratic Party base became composed of individuals with an interest in liberalizing the existing laws with respect to abortion, the party became “pro-choice” meaning in favor of either federal legislation or judicial action legalizing abortion on demand. In this case, the term liberal from a literal perspective appears to be more in-keeping with the moniker. The change however was made because of the demands of an active, large and growing interest group within the Democratic Party and the liberal establishment. Does that mean that pre-1973 the Democratic Party was conservative not liberal? Yes and no, the point here is that these terms are completely fluid and ultimately without lasting/foundational meaning. What is favored today may be shunned tomorrow by either. To say that one is either liberal or conservative without clarification/amplification is really to reveal almost nothing other than the affiliation of one’s current power-base.
Will to Power
Perhaps more astoundingly, the terms liberal and conservative have no cohesive/conceptual underpinnings which might unify the various disparate strains which make up each. In some respects, liberals appear to espouse conservative policies, in others, conservatives embrace liberal ones. Neoconservatives as has already been mentioned embrace aggressive foreign policy including preventive wars of aggression. This in reality is a very liberal not conservative view. Analogously, most liberals currently oppose foreign wars of aggression and excessive U.S. militarism (in the maintenance of American hegemony) despite the fact that to do so is really a traditionally conservative position. Thoughtful persons find that neither political party has a consistent underlying conceptually unified organizing principle. What then attracts the vast majority of people to one or the other belief system? In the absence of any core worldview orientation it appears that the choice of one or the other is based solely on the need to posses a power-base from which to operate i.e. a special interest. Since third parties (political) have not been successful in the United States, the choices available are either liberal/conservative, Democrat/Republican irrespective of the fact that these terms are constantly changing and without ultimate meaning.
The media (talk-radio and cable especially) essentially mirror this artificial division. For example, Fox News represents the Neoconservative position; MSNBC largely reflects the Liberal or Progressive viewpoint. Similar divisions characterize talk-radio. Traditional or Paleoconservative views are left largely unrepresented by the corporate media with a few exceptions (e.g. Patrick J. Buchanan).
Part of the current bi-polar split involves a separation between Secularism and Traditionalism as the United States progressively abandons all semblance of Tradition in favor of Secular Humanism. While liberalism/progressivism almost entirely ascribes to Secularism, there remain parts of the “conservative” coalition which attempt to adhere to more traditionalist views—primarily those Paleoconservatives from whom the Neoconservatives have rested control of the Republican Party. Nevertheless, even here, there is a great deal of overlap. For example, the so-called Libertarian wing of conservatism favors the liberalization of controlled substance laws e.g. Marijuana which most Paleoconservatives oppose. In that sense, Libertarians are much more like liberals (progressives) than traditional conservatives. They are more inclined to accept gay “marriage” than are Paleoconservatives on the grounds of individual liberty or on the basis of civil or personal “rights” criteria. These rights however are fictitious in that they are ungrounded in any fixed or foundational human anthropology (nature or essence). That is to say since the Enlightenment and in the wake of Darwinism (Darwinian philosophy or metaphysical naturalism), human nature is assumed to be fluid. Modern "rights" simply refer to the constantly changing desires/choices which various individuals and groups wish to see codified in the law from time to time.
It becomes apparent that the artificial bi-polar split articulated here is completely without ideological foundation. Evidence seems to indicate that it has become a favored mechanism by which the ruling elites exercise control over the masses. In reality this amounts to a kind of not so subtle Hegelian “brain-washing” which is utilized to change public opinion by making it appear that issues are being fairly debated and democratically resolved. One feels forced to conclude that the binary worldview is nothing but a ruse--a kind of “bread and circus” extravaganza which functions to keep the proletariat pacified while the oligarchical elites proceed with advancing their goals.
As long as political discourse is limited to a one-dimensional binary charade in which the elite power broker’s of the Regime manage all public discourse utilizing a kind of Hegelian dialectic, it will be impossible for Americans to alter their government and the status quo will be maintained. Surely it is obvious that most issues are at least “3” dimensional meaning that more than the question of the amount of government control or lack of same should be at stake. If we are to add for example the moral dimension (in this case a kind of “Y” axis) or any other dimension which mirror’s reality, we must discard once and for all the new bipolar one-dimensional worldview.
A blog which is dedicated to the use of Traditional (Aristotelian/Thomistic) moral reasoning in the analysis of current events. Readers are challenged to reject the Hegelian Dialectic and go beyond the customary Left/Right, Liberal/Conservative One--Dimensional Divide. This site is not-for-profit. The information contained here-in is for educational and personal enrichment purposes only. Please generously share all material with others. --Dr. J. P. Hubert
Showing posts sorted by date for query Traditional Marriage. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Traditional Marriage. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Friday, August 27, 2010
Sunday, August 15, 2010
“Police-State” Tactics Replace Traditional Moral Restraint
By: Dr. J. P. Hubert
Legal Stringency vs. Legal Laxity:
Not everything that is immoral is illegal in the West. There would be insufficient numbers of police and prosecuting attorney’s to process all of the crimes were that to be the case. As a result, some behaviors which are clearly immoral based on tradition moral precepts[1] are not made criminal e.g. adultery, homosexual activity, fornication etc (in Muslim countries which observe Sharia law however, many of these immoral behaviors are considered crimes and punished severely meaning their societies are legally stringent). The degree to which immoral behavior is not made criminal is a measure of the legal laxity of a society. For a detailed discussion of the relationship of the "Common Good" to Civil Law and human virtue see: Thomas Aquinas. Summa Theologiae, I-II, 96, 1-6 HERE...
Not all Immoral Acts are Illegal and Vice-Versa:
On the other hand, most things that are illegal are immoral, e.g. murder, rape, theft etc. Clearly there are some minor crimes e.g. failure to pay a parking ticket in a timely fashion which are either morally neutral or of minimal significance compared to major criminal activity. For all intents and purposes then, there exist few crimes which are not immoral as well. If too many clearly moral acts were punishable by law, not only would enforcement be impossible but justice would be unattainable as the civil law would be capricious and confidence in it would be destroyed.
The Correct Balance of Civil Laws and Moral Code:
The ideal balance in society is for major immoral actions/behaviors to be punishable by law as well. However, as a society loses its traditional moral integrity, it becomes necessary to substitute increasingly more and more stringent laws to serve as a substitute for the moral restraint which was once practiced by the populace. Taken to the extreme, a “police-state” will be required in cases where there has been a significant repudiation of traditional morality in practice. Such societal moral depravity simply cannot be controlled by stringent police-state tactics. There is no effective substitute for individual and societal moral restraint since it is impossible to place a police officer in every home, on every street corner and so forth.
Inverse Relationship between Morality and Civil Law:
For ease of handling, one might think of morality and civil laws then as being inversely proportional to one another. Where there is a high degree of morality in a population, there is less need for prohibitive laws and large numbers of police to enforce them. Where there is moral depravity, more and more legal impediments must be erected to control human behavior and a larger number of police and prosecutors are required to enforce them. This of course assumes that it is possible to determine right and wrong in the first instance which many Post-Modernists/Utilitarian’s/Hedonist’s/Moral Relativist’s often deny. [Not only do they argue that there is no truth (an epistemological claim) but that there is no fixed morality (a moral philosophical claim)]. Most proponents of post-modernism adopt some sort of Moral Relativism or Utilitarianism in which determinations of right and wrong become reflections of what is socially acceptable at a given time. Needless to say, that is a prescription for moral anarchy but unfortunately describes quite well the current situation in the “developed” West.
The Need for a Fixed Moral Code:
In any case, despite the claims of self-professed nihilists and other non-traditional moralist’s everyone behaves in their interpersonal relations as if a fixed moral code exists. For example, we all appeal to fairness if we believe that we are being treated inequitably. To say that we must be accorded fair treatment is to imply that a standard exists by which to determine fairness. That standard might be thought of loosely as the Natural (moral) law, what for example C.S. Lewis termed the Tau in his Mere Christianity, (San Francisco: Harper, 1952).
[2] In order for there to be a standard by which all can be equally judged, there must be a universal reality to which all may appeal. That reality can be thought of as our human nature or anthropology which is fixed by virtue of our being members of the human race. In a certain sense it is specific to our DNA although not simply an epiphenomenon of it. That fixed human nature or “being” then which exists in every person is the standard or template the “is” from which all behavior or “ought’s” must be derived.
It is pointless to argue that human nature or “being” is fluid and not fixed. Quite apart from the ontological implications which have been debated ad nauseum in the biological realm, if we do not assume a fixed human anthropology, it is impossible to devise a workable moral code to which all human beings can be held. The result is to render meaningless such statements as: “All human beings are entitled to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” or “all human beings should be treated equally” or “it is always and everywhere wrong to intentionally kill an innocent human being.” Under such a rubric (fluidity of human nature) it is impossible to derive any human rights at all since they become nothing more than claims which certain people advance from time to time against the ruling authority, which ultimately have no basis in fact or reality.
Their existence is as impermanent as the political power possessed at a given moment by the reference group or individual in question. That is to say even if a given human right is granted temporarily there is no basis upon which to believe that it will remain so. Moreover, when it is impossible to determine right from wrong because it is constantly changing we induce a societal form of cognitive dissonance. People assume a sort of “every man for himself” mentality. The result is selfishness, greed and often all encompassing hedonistic pursuits instead of selflessness, generosity and the seeking of the “common good.”
Human Rights must be based on a Fixed Human Nature:
What we have then is the truth that human rights must be tied to the fixed reality of human "being" or nature. If we assume instead that human anthropology is fluid, that human nature is not fixed or is indeterminate; we have moral anarchy due to the lack of a suitable universal referent. Tragically that is pretty much the case currently in the “developed” West and is also the main reason that much of the so-called third world a large percentage of which is Muslim finds us to be morally repugnant.
Quite apart from what we may see as the repressive nature of fundamentalist Islamic mores’, the actual moral code (as separated from the sanctions which enforce it) is much more compatible with traditional (Aristotelian/Thomistic) morality than that which is practiced in the West since it is based upon a more accurate assessment of human nature.[3] The Islamic moral code is simply closer to traditional (what was once termed Judeo-Christian) morality than is the Moral Relativism and Utilitarianism which has overtaken us.[4]
Where Christianity is different is that it proposes a complete or total spiritual conversion of the individual (through the power of the atoning death of Jesus Christ on the Cross) as the deterent against evil rather than the severe system of corporal punishment which is associated with Islamic Sharia law. In the former it is the positive transformation of the human person into an entirely "new creature in Christ" in the latter the negative reinforcement of physical injury or death. The Christian emphasis is on conversion and mercy while still maintaining a strict moral code, the Islamic emphasis is on an Old Testament form of severe retributive attempt at justice.
Historically over the past 50 years traditional (Aristotelian/Thomistic) morality has been progressively replaced in the United States and much of the West by a combination of Utilitarianism and Moral Relativism. This has been combined with a marked change in the judicial system from what was primarily Natural Law based jurisprudence to one of Legal Positivism or Pragmatism.[5] With the loss of traditional moral precepts there has been the expected increase in immoral behavior which to wit has been associated with a marked increase in law-breaking on the part of individuals and powerful group entities (such as major corporations, the Congress and the Executive branch of the US government).
Societal Moral Depravity Promotes Advent of Police State:
Some in the research community contend that Neo-fascist tactics are the result primarily of authoritarian personalities who periodically come to power and that fascist governments represent the occasional outlier or idiosyncratic development. Little recognized perhaps is the fact that when traditional morality is abandoned by a society, it becomes much easier for nefarious forces to introduce police-state tactics.
For example, in the wake of the 911 terrorist attacks, fascist neo-Nazi tactics were quite easily adopted e.g. USA Patriot Act, attempted suspension of Habeas Corpus, Torture of Prisoners, and Rendition etc. In part this was due to the fear which gripped the nation. The fact however that for decade’s traditional morality had been degraded adds to the ease with which heretofore unimaginable infringements were made on human rights. We had in a sense become accustomed to the need for prohibitive laws which took the place of traditional moral behavior in the aggregate. The corporate media was enlisted to convince[6] average Americans that we must even surrender certain of our basic human rights and liberty in order to ensure our national and individual security. Of course that would be unnecessary if as neighbors we trusted each other to do right and to be virtuous. The fact that we don’t should tell us something profound about our moral climate currently.
In the absence of a return to traditional morality as a nation, we will find it increasingly necessary to adopt more and more draconian laws by which to control human behavior. That is simply an inevitable outcome which results from the existence of the Natural (moral) law. If human beings will not voluntarily submit to the precepts of the Natural Law, then they will be forced to do so at the point of a gun or from behind prison walls.
The only other option is complete societal dissolution/anarchy where all positive civil law is suspended and where violence and a “might makes right” vigilantism is in force. The latter development is unlikely as long as our current oligarch’s maintain authoritarian control through progressively more stringent laws and prohibitions. The institution of Marshal-Law would be the logical next step or end-result of a further degradation in societal morality.
911 and a Constitutional Coup d'état Facilitated Police-State:
Professor Francis A Boyle a leading light in the area of constitutional and international law maintains that the US constitution has already been subjected to a Coup d'état in the wake of the 9/11 attacks and the signing of the USA Patriot Act, attempted suspension of Habeas Corpus and the practice of Torture and Rendition.[7] If he is correct than we are further along the path outlined above than I would have hoped. Boyle of course sees the problem as our not being willing to abide by international law and the treaties we have signed which have made them a part of US domestic law. He is certainly correct as far as it goes. The more fundamental underlying reason in this writer’s estimation however is the increasing moral depravity of the ruling elites which has now percolated down to the level of the average American. The “ruling class” should be very nervous now that the so-called “common man” has adopted their immoral code and jettisoned traditional morality. Historically, this is when “the natives get restless” and the Oligarchical regime is most potentially threatened by the masses who are no longer governed by a desire for justice rather than vengeance or a love of the common good.
To put a finer point on this concept; people often assume that is, take-on the morality of the civil law in which they reside. When the oligarchical regime intentionally adulterates the traditional morality of a society by moving it in the direction of Hedonism/Utilitarianism/Moral Relativism through the legislative process and the courts, the new “moral code” is eventually embraced by the masses. If something is made legal which previously was not, it is assumed to be moral and vice-versa. For example, after abortion was legalized in 1974; many Americans insufficiently grounded in traditional moral precepts decided it must be moral. This was made easier due to the fact that the political class and special interest groups engaged in a form of rank sophistry[8] rather than a probative analysis and debate regarding the actual biological, philosophical and religious implications involved. That sadly is still the case today.
Another example is the issue of gay “marriage” which while illegal in a majority of states and previously thought to be immoral by a majority of Americans, is rapidly becoming acceptable and is in the process of being legalized throughout the United States. The national trajectory is now in the direction of the legalization of gay “marriage” and along with it the assumption that gay “marriage must be morally licit.[9] The point is that the ruling elite’s who have abandoned traditional morality are able through their control of the political process and the media to normalize virtually any aberrant or immoral behavior. As they do so, they must enact increasingly more stringent laws to control the choices (many of which are largely immoral from the perspective of traditional morality) which the populace wishes to make and act upon.
Conclusion:
As a nation we have abandoned traditional morality in favor of a hodge-podge of non-moral philosophical theories including Utilitarianism, Moral Relativism and Hedonism all of which ultimately translate to personal selfishness. We no longer care about the “common good.” This has made it necessary and easy to establish a more and more stringent “police-state” domestically in order to control our now unbridled passions. Such things as “hate-crime” legislation are a good example of the result where the law now attempts to ascertain the moral intention of a given perpetrator of a crime. Needless to say this is not only legally improper but is unlikely to be effective. The proper place to consider “intention” is at the level of the moral analysis which should take place prior to the performance of a given act.
Just as in the case of gay “marriage” bans, the problem is not a legal one it is a moral one in this case the repudiation of traditional morality at the level of nation-state. In the history of the world, there is no precedent at the nation state level for reversing the current situation in which the common morality has been so seriously adulterated. Moral depravity of a nation predisposes to its self destruction from within and the foolhardy overextension of empire from without. For more see THIS... and THIS... That reality (US moral depravity) means that the survival of the American experiment (barring a fundamental change in national morality and or Divine intervention) is in doubt.
NOTES:
[1] When I refer to “traditional morality” or traditional moral precepts I mean Aristotelian/Thomistic moral philosophical principles, what some have called the Judeo-Christian ethic in the past although technically, the latter is less precise than the former in terms of performing a proper moral analysis of a given moral question. Some have utilized the phrase “golden-rule” ethic to summarize what they mean by traditional morality which is also less concise than the Aristotelian/Thomistic Synthesis. Human actions which are immoral from the perspective of traditional morality are not arbitrarily so characterized. The determination is made on the basis of what it means to be human or have a human nature and how a given human being is best able to actualize the attainment of the ultimate goal which is the Sumum Bonum or supreme good.
[2] Lewis made a variant of the so-called Moral argument for the existence of God and demonstrated that it was this that in large part was responsible for his conversion from atheism first to pantheism and then to Christianity. Today we have the interesting development that a notorious atheist philosopher has converted to Theism based primarily on the Design argument reworked in light of contemporary Astrophysics data which demonstrate that the physical constants of the universe are incredibly “fine-tuned.”
[3] This is to be expected since the Muslim philosopher’s were aware of the work of Aristotle’s metaphysics, philosophy of nature and his Ethics. In fact it is they who preserved his teaching throughout the Dark Ages prior to the time of Albert Magnus (St. Albert the Great) and Thomas Aquinas who combined Aristotelian philosophy with Christianity. For an excellent treatment of the Philosophy of Nature see William A. Wallace O.P. THE MODELING OF NATURE: PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE AND PHILOSOPHY OF NATURE IN SYNTHESIS.(The Catholic University of America Press, Washington, D.C. 20064, 1996). Click HERE...for a short video by Professor Wallace.
[4] The irony here is that the Neoconservative/Neo-Nazi political right which has taken over the Republican Party and the Neo-liberal left the Democratic Party are both further away from traditional morality than Muslim morality based as it is in Aristotle’s metaphysics and ethical theory. In Islamic societies in which there is no Radical Jihadism and absent Sharia, the moral climate is much closer to traditional morality than is the current immoral one found in the United States. Moreover, the Neoconservatives and Neoliberals largely embrace the Neo-Nazi moral philosophy of the Radical Zionist’s who now control modern Israel e.g. all accept the immoral “Bush Doctrine” of preventive war.
[5] John P. Hubert, “The “Fruits” of Legal Positivism: Utilitarianism in Action”, Intellectual Conservative, 09 December 2005, HERE....
[6] The FCM have taken on the role of the ancient Greek Sophists in manipulating public opinion on behalf of the ruling oligarch’s.
[7] Francis A. Boyle. Tackling America’s Toughest Questions, (Atlanta Ga: Clarity Press, 2009), pp. 39-47.
[8] Rather than asking if abortion intentionally kills an innocent human being (which is always and everywhere wrong according to traditional morality), proponents framed the issue as one of a women’s “right” to control her reproductive process. Such a “right” however does not exist in traditional morality based as it is on a fixed human anthropology. The USSC has said that such a “right” exists in the Constitution of the US (a debatable issue in itself) even though no such moral “right” could be found unless the court abandoned Natural Law jurisprudence in exchange for Legal Pragmatism. See footnote # 5 for details.
[9] See my blog post “The Problem with Gay Marriage Bans” HERE.... For additional background on Traditional Marriage contrasted with Gay “Marriage see THIS....
Legal Stringency vs. Legal Laxity:
Not everything that is immoral is illegal in the West. There would be insufficient numbers of police and prosecuting attorney’s to process all of the crimes were that to be the case. As a result, some behaviors which are clearly immoral based on tradition moral precepts[1] are not made criminal e.g. adultery, homosexual activity, fornication etc (in Muslim countries which observe Sharia law however, many of these immoral behaviors are considered crimes and punished severely meaning their societies are legally stringent). The degree to which immoral behavior is not made criminal is a measure of the legal laxity of a society. For a detailed discussion of the relationship of the "Common Good" to Civil Law and human virtue see: Thomas Aquinas. Summa Theologiae, I-II, 96, 1-6 HERE...
Not all Immoral Acts are Illegal and Vice-Versa:
On the other hand, most things that are illegal are immoral, e.g. murder, rape, theft etc. Clearly there are some minor crimes e.g. failure to pay a parking ticket in a timely fashion which are either morally neutral or of minimal significance compared to major criminal activity. For all intents and purposes then, there exist few crimes which are not immoral as well. If too many clearly moral acts were punishable by law, not only would enforcement be impossible but justice would be unattainable as the civil law would be capricious and confidence in it would be destroyed.
The Correct Balance of Civil Laws and Moral Code:
The ideal balance in society is for major immoral actions/behaviors to be punishable by law as well. However, as a society loses its traditional moral integrity, it becomes necessary to substitute increasingly more and more stringent laws to serve as a substitute for the moral restraint which was once practiced by the populace. Taken to the extreme, a “police-state” will be required in cases where there has been a significant repudiation of traditional morality in practice. Such societal moral depravity simply cannot be controlled by stringent police-state tactics. There is no effective substitute for individual and societal moral restraint since it is impossible to place a police officer in every home, on every street corner and so forth.
Inverse Relationship between Morality and Civil Law:
For ease of handling, one might think of morality and civil laws then as being inversely proportional to one another. Where there is a high degree of morality in a population, there is less need for prohibitive laws and large numbers of police to enforce them. Where there is moral depravity, more and more legal impediments must be erected to control human behavior and a larger number of police and prosecutors are required to enforce them. This of course assumes that it is possible to determine right and wrong in the first instance which many Post-Modernists/Utilitarian’s/Hedonist’s/Moral Relativist’s often deny. [Not only do they argue that there is no truth (an epistemological claim) but that there is no fixed morality (a moral philosophical claim)]. Most proponents of post-modernism adopt some sort of Moral Relativism or Utilitarianism in which determinations of right and wrong become reflections of what is socially acceptable at a given time. Needless to say, that is a prescription for moral anarchy but unfortunately describes quite well the current situation in the “developed” West.
The Need for a Fixed Moral Code:
In any case, despite the claims of self-professed nihilists and other non-traditional moralist’s everyone behaves in their interpersonal relations as if a fixed moral code exists. For example, we all appeal to fairness if we believe that we are being treated inequitably. To say that we must be accorded fair treatment is to imply that a standard exists by which to determine fairness. That standard might be thought of loosely as the Natural (moral) law, what for example C.S. Lewis termed the Tau in his Mere Christianity, (San Francisco: Harper, 1952).
[2] In order for there to be a standard by which all can be equally judged, there must be a universal reality to which all may appeal. That reality can be thought of as our human nature or anthropology which is fixed by virtue of our being members of the human race. In a certain sense it is specific to our DNA although not simply an epiphenomenon of it. That fixed human nature or “being” then which exists in every person is the standard or template the “is” from which all behavior or “ought’s” must be derived.
It is pointless to argue that human nature or “being” is fluid and not fixed. Quite apart from the ontological implications which have been debated ad nauseum in the biological realm, if we do not assume a fixed human anthropology, it is impossible to devise a workable moral code to which all human beings can be held. The result is to render meaningless such statements as: “All human beings are entitled to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” or “all human beings should be treated equally” or “it is always and everywhere wrong to intentionally kill an innocent human being.” Under such a rubric (fluidity of human nature) it is impossible to derive any human rights at all since they become nothing more than claims which certain people advance from time to time against the ruling authority, which ultimately have no basis in fact or reality.
Their existence is as impermanent as the political power possessed at a given moment by the reference group or individual in question. That is to say even if a given human right is granted temporarily there is no basis upon which to believe that it will remain so. Moreover, when it is impossible to determine right from wrong because it is constantly changing we induce a societal form of cognitive dissonance. People assume a sort of “every man for himself” mentality. The result is selfishness, greed and often all encompassing hedonistic pursuits instead of selflessness, generosity and the seeking of the “common good.”
Human Rights must be based on a Fixed Human Nature:
What we have then is the truth that human rights must be tied to the fixed reality of human "being" or nature. If we assume instead that human anthropology is fluid, that human nature is not fixed or is indeterminate; we have moral anarchy due to the lack of a suitable universal referent. Tragically that is pretty much the case currently in the “developed” West and is also the main reason that much of the so-called third world a large percentage of which is Muslim finds us to be morally repugnant.
Quite apart from what we may see as the repressive nature of fundamentalist Islamic mores’, the actual moral code (as separated from the sanctions which enforce it) is much more compatible with traditional (Aristotelian/Thomistic) morality than that which is practiced in the West since it is based upon a more accurate assessment of human nature.[3] The Islamic moral code is simply closer to traditional (what was once termed Judeo-Christian) morality than is the Moral Relativism and Utilitarianism which has overtaken us.[4]
Where Christianity is different is that it proposes a complete or total spiritual conversion of the individual (through the power of the atoning death of Jesus Christ on the Cross) as the deterent against evil rather than the severe system of corporal punishment which is associated with Islamic Sharia law. In the former it is the positive transformation of the human person into an entirely "new creature in Christ" in the latter the negative reinforcement of physical injury or death. The Christian emphasis is on conversion and mercy while still maintaining a strict moral code, the Islamic emphasis is on an Old Testament form of severe retributive attempt at justice.
Historically over the past 50 years traditional (Aristotelian/Thomistic) morality has been progressively replaced in the United States and much of the West by a combination of Utilitarianism and Moral Relativism. This has been combined with a marked change in the judicial system from what was primarily Natural Law based jurisprudence to one of Legal Positivism or Pragmatism.[5] With the loss of traditional moral precepts there has been the expected increase in immoral behavior which to wit has been associated with a marked increase in law-breaking on the part of individuals and powerful group entities (such as major corporations, the Congress and the Executive branch of the US government).
Societal Moral Depravity Promotes Advent of Police State:
Some in the research community contend that Neo-fascist tactics are the result primarily of authoritarian personalities who periodically come to power and that fascist governments represent the occasional outlier or idiosyncratic development. Little recognized perhaps is the fact that when traditional morality is abandoned by a society, it becomes much easier for nefarious forces to introduce police-state tactics.
For example, in the wake of the 911 terrorist attacks, fascist neo-Nazi tactics were quite easily adopted e.g. USA Patriot Act, attempted suspension of Habeas Corpus, Torture of Prisoners, and Rendition etc. In part this was due to the fear which gripped the nation. The fact however that for decade’s traditional morality had been degraded adds to the ease with which heretofore unimaginable infringements were made on human rights. We had in a sense become accustomed to the need for prohibitive laws which took the place of traditional moral behavior in the aggregate. The corporate media was enlisted to convince[6] average Americans that we must even surrender certain of our basic human rights and liberty in order to ensure our national and individual security. Of course that would be unnecessary if as neighbors we trusted each other to do right and to be virtuous. The fact that we don’t should tell us something profound about our moral climate currently.
In the absence of a return to traditional morality as a nation, we will find it increasingly necessary to adopt more and more draconian laws by which to control human behavior. That is simply an inevitable outcome which results from the existence of the Natural (moral) law. If human beings will not voluntarily submit to the precepts of the Natural Law, then they will be forced to do so at the point of a gun or from behind prison walls.
The only other option is complete societal dissolution/anarchy where all positive civil law is suspended and where violence and a “might makes right” vigilantism is in force. The latter development is unlikely as long as our current oligarch’s maintain authoritarian control through progressively more stringent laws and prohibitions. The institution of Marshal-Law would be the logical next step or end-result of a further degradation in societal morality.
911 and a Constitutional Coup d'état Facilitated Police-State:
Professor Francis A Boyle a leading light in the area of constitutional and international law maintains that the US constitution has already been subjected to a Coup d'état in the wake of the 9/11 attacks and the signing of the USA Patriot Act, attempted suspension of Habeas Corpus and the practice of Torture and Rendition.[7] If he is correct than we are further along the path outlined above than I would have hoped. Boyle of course sees the problem as our not being willing to abide by international law and the treaties we have signed which have made them a part of US domestic law. He is certainly correct as far as it goes. The more fundamental underlying reason in this writer’s estimation however is the increasing moral depravity of the ruling elites which has now percolated down to the level of the average American. The “ruling class” should be very nervous now that the so-called “common man” has adopted their immoral code and jettisoned traditional morality. Historically, this is when “the natives get restless” and the Oligarchical regime is most potentially threatened by the masses who are no longer governed by a desire for justice rather than vengeance or a love of the common good.
To put a finer point on this concept; people often assume that is, take-on the morality of the civil law in which they reside. When the oligarchical regime intentionally adulterates the traditional morality of a society by moving it in the direction of Hedonism/Utilitarianism/Moral Relativism through the legislative process and the courts, the new “moral code” is eventually embraced by the masses. If something is made legal which previously was not, it is assumed to be moral and vice-versa. For example, after abortion was legalized in 1974; many Americans insufficiently grounded in traditional moral precepts decided it must be moral. This was made easier due to the fact that the political class and special interest groups engaged in a form of rank sophistry[8] rather than a probative analysis and debate regarding the actual biological, philosophical and religious implications involved. That sadly is still the case today.
Another example is the issue of gay “marriage” which while illegal in a majority of states and previously thought to be immoral by a majority of Americans, is rapidly becoming acceptable and is in the process of being legalized throughout the United States. The national trajectory is now in the direction of the legalization of gay “marriage” and along with it the assumption that gay “marriage must be morally licit.[9] The point is that the ruling elite’s who have abandoned traditional morality are able through their control of the political process and the media to normalize virtually any aberrant or immoral behavior. As they do so, they must enact increasingly more stringent laws to control the choices (many of which are largely immoral from the perspective of traditional morality) which the populace wishes to make and act upon.
Conclusion:
As a nation we have abandoned traditional morality in favor of a hodge-podge of non-moral philosophical theories including Utilitarianism, Moral Relativism and Hedonism all of which ultimately translate to personal selfishness. We no longer care about the “common good.” This has made it necessary and easy to establish a more and more stringent “police-state” domestically in order to control our now unbridled passions. Such things as “hate-crime” legislation are a good example of the result where the law now attempts to ascertain the moral intention of a given perpetrator of a crime. Needless to say this is not only legally improper but is unlikely to be effective. The proper place to consider “intention” is at the level of the moral analysis which should take place prior to the performance of a given act.
Just as in the case of gay “marriage” bans, the problem is not a legal one it is a moral one in this case the repudiation of traditional morality at the level of nation-state. In the history of the world, there is no precedent at the nation state level for reversing the current situation in which the common morality has been so seriously adulterated. Moral depravity of a nation predisposes to its self destruction from within and the foolhardy overextension of empire from without. For more see THIS... and THIS... That reality (US moral depravity) means that the survival of the American experiment (barring a fundamental change in national morality and or Divine intervention) is in doubt.
NOTES:
[1] When I refer to “traditional morality” or traditional moral precepts I mean Aristotelian/Thomistic moral philosophical principles, what some have called the Judeo-Christian ethic in the past although technically, the latter is less precise than the former in terms of performing a proper moral analysis of a given moral question. Some have utilized the phrase “golden-rule” ethic to summarize what they mean by traditional morality which is also less concise than the Aristotelian/Thomistic Synthesis. Human actions which are immoral from the perspective of traditional morality are not arbitrarily so characterized. The determination is made on the basis of what it means to be human or have a human nature and how a given human being is best able to actualize the attainment of the ultimate goal which is the Sumum Bonum or supreme good.
[2] Lewis made a variant of the so-called Moral argument for the existence of God and demonstrated that it was this that in large part was responsible for his conversion from atheism first to pantheism and then to Christianity. Today we have the interesting development that a notorious atheist philosopher has converted to Theism based primarily on the Design argument reworked in light of contemporary Astrophysics data which demonstrate that the physical constants of the universe are incredibly “fine-tuned.”
[3] This is to be expected since the Muslim philosopher’s were aware of the work of Aristotle’s metaphysics, philosophy of nature and his Ethics. In fact it is they who preserved his teaching throughout the Dark Ages prior to the time of Albert Magnus (St. Albert the Great) and Thomas Aquinas who combined Aristotelian philosophy with Christianity. For an excellent treatment of the Philosophy of Nature see William A. Wallace O.P. THE MODELING OF NATURE: PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE AND PHILOSOPHY OF NATURE IN SYNTHESIS.(The Catholic University of America Press, Washington, D.C. 20064, 1996). Click HERE...for a short video by Professor Wallace.
[4] The irony here is that the Neoconservative/Neo-Nazi political right which has taken over the Republican Party and the Neo-liberal left the Democratic Party are both further away from traditional morality than Muslim morality based as it is in Aristotle’s metaphysics and ethical theory. In Islamic societies in which there is no Radical Jihadism and absent Sharia, the moral climate is much closer to traditional morality than is the current immoral one found in the United States. Moreover, the Neoconservatives and Neoliberals largely embrace the Neo-Nazi moral philosophy of the Radical Zionist’s who now control modern Israel e.g. all accept the immoral “Bush Doctrine” of preventive war.
[5] John P. Hubert, “The “Fruits” of Legal Positivism: Utilitarianism in Action”, Intellectual Conservative, 09 December 2005, HERE....
[6] The FCM have taken on the role of the ancient Greek Sophists in manipulating public opinion on behalf of the ruling oligarch’s.
[7] Francis A. Boyle. Tackling America’s Toughest Questions, (Atlanta Ga: Clarity Press, 2009), pp. 39-47.
[8] Rather than asking if abortion intentionally kills an innocent human being (which is always and everywhere wrong according to traditional morality), proponents framed the issue as one of a women’s “right” to control her reproductive process. Such a “right” however does not exist in traditional morality based as it is on a fixed human anthropology. The USSC has said that such a “right” exists in the Constitution of the US (a debatable issue in itself) even though no such moral “right” could be found unless the court abandoned Natural Law jurisprudence in exchange for Legal Pragmatism. See footnote # 5 for details.
[9] See my blog post “The Problem with Gay Marriage Bans” HERE.... For additional background on Traditional Marriage contrasted with Gay “Marriage see THIS....
Friday, August 6, 2010
More on Gay "Marriage"
Editor's NOTE:
In response to my editorial comment of yesterday regarding the overturning of the California Proposition 8 ban on Gay "Marriage" several readers have asked that this essay which I penned a while back be posted again in order that they might have access to critical philosophical concepts located therein. This may be seen as a companion piece to what was posted yesterday where a link was provided to the article I wrote for the Intellectual Conservative in 2005.
What of Non-Traditional Marriage?
By: Dr. J. P. Hubert
Over the past several years marked interest has grown in what must for the sake of intellectual honesty be termed non-traditional “marriage.” By this is usually meant “civil unions” or arrangements in which same-sex couples formalize their relationship and in so doing derive the benefits usually reserved for married heterosexual couples. To date, little organized interest has been expressed for other kinds of non-traditional “marriages” such as polygamous ones or those involving animals and humans (bestiality). In any case it has now become necessary to flesh-out the philosophical implications of marriage including the nature of what it means to be a human person and what is meant by “tradition.”
As mathematician/physicist and philosopher Wolfgang Smith has taught, “traditional” when used as an adjective before anything connotes the transcendent not simply ancient or of historical significance. To say that marriage for example is traditionally a life-long commitment between one man and one woman is to say in part that it is based in the transcendent “other” which theists understand as God (being personified from a philosophical perspective); that it “embodies an element of revelation.” According to Smith, a “doctrine is traditional by virtue of the fact that it partakes somewhat of eternity.” In this sense traditional marriage is not only a horizontal but a vertical relationship (metaphysical reality) with God as one of the “partners.”
To develop this concept a bit further, traditional marriage (TM) is a microcosm/reflection of penultimate being that is, non-derivative being in much the same way that man was created in the imago Dei (image of God, Gen. 1:26). Orthodox Catholics understand it as a recapitulation of the Trinity [tri-unity (“3” who’s in one what)] that is the Blessed Trinity—wherein the “two (male and female possessing complementarity) become one flesh” (Gen. 2: 24) in the sense of giving life to a child (the third member of the human triad/family, not simply copulation between the 2 adults). From the perspective of human anthropology (nature or essence) marriage, in a traditional sense can join only one man and one woman in a permanent (covenant in religious terms) or exclusive relationship if it is to retain any semblance of meaning. As such the Traditional marriage union is a metaphysical (outside of space and time) reality as well as a physical one which is unbreakable by human means. It is this facet of traditional marriage which has been expunged in large part from post-modernity by the way.
The notion that individuals of the same sex or that multiple partners (in the sense of the simultaneous pleural marriages practiced by polygamists) could “marry” is to rob the term “traditional” marriage of any real meaning. These and other “unions” such as between humans and animals are non-traditional in the extreme. Not only do they fail to mirror in microcosm the transcendent other (GOD) as understood in Christianity, they for the most part lack complementarity (anatomically at least) as well. While pleural marriage (simultaneous or serial) on an anatomic basis may possess complementarity, it clearly lacks exclusivity. Traditional marriage then for Christians must contain the elements of complementarity and exclusivity. This is true because of the essence of what it means to be human and because traditional marriage has both a vertical and a horizontal dimension, one in space and time; one outside of or beyond it. Unfortunately, the Enlightenment, much of modern philosophy (particularly the Utilitarianism of J. S. Mill) including Cartesian Dualism followed on by Baconian notions of science including Darwinist philosophy (philosophical naturalism) have emptied traditional marriage of its true meaning. The details of these assaults on traditional marriage (TM) are beyond the scope of this short essay. However, suffice it to say that as a result of the above--human nature is no longer considered “fixed.” It is simply assumed that one can create their own nature and for that matter reality itself. This reduces marriage to a completely horizontal “arrangement” of our own making that can be undone at will--resembling something more akin to a business transaction.
Admittedly, the idea that marriage is a recapitulation of the Blessed Trinity is unique to Christianity as it is predicated on a unique and divinely revealed understanding of the nature of God. Both Judaism and Islam which either tacitly or explicitly reject the Blessed Trinity; have historically allowed simultaneous pleural marriage between human beings, (multiple wives with one husband) usually on economic, or other utilitarian grounds including custom. Nevertheless, over time, each has moved away from the practice of polygamy. It is safe to say that no monotheistic religion has endorsed non-traditional marriage between adult human beings of the same sex or between humans and animals presumably because of the issue of lack of complementarity and the recognition that traditional marriage (TM) in order to be legitimate/genuine must contain no impediment to the natural generation of children which would ensue from a lack of complementarity. This is another way of saying that marriage arrangements must not be incompatible with the Natural Law. Procreation--and with it the education and rearing of children--has traditionally been seen as either the primary/only or dual reason for marriage (along with the obvious positive unitive benefit for the spouses). Clearly this is an impossibility in the natural for same-sex and human/animal “unions.” Moreover, incest (parent/child) in recorded history has universally been sanctioned in all of the “3” monotheistic religions at least in part for reasons having to do with complications arising as a direct result of copulation and procreation (genetic disorders for example among other severe psychological problems).
While heterosexual incest is correctly ordered anatomically, it is clearly disordered from the perspective of lacking exclusivity (parents already have or should have a monogamous and exclusive relationship), genetic complications and behavioral problems. Since traditional morality holds that sexual intercourse is proper only within the bounds of marriage, it is apparent that incest could never be morally acceptable. Even in the event of death of one of the marriage partners, incest (sexual relations with one or more of the children) would be immoral on multiple other grounds including on the basis that in doing so, the remaining marriage partner would be guilty of a sin against charity with respect to the children. This would be true even if for some misguided reason the offspring were said to have given “consent.”
Some would argue that while same-sex human or opposite-sex human/animal “unions” are not marriage in the Traditional sense, pleural marriage between for example one man and multiple women should be afforded the designation “traditional marriage.” There is a certain logic to this contention in that complementarity is preserved and with it the ability to procreate. The difficulty comes in that there is no exclusivity of the partners or of their offspring for the biological parents, thus not as organically related families in these arrangements. Such “unions” fail to recapitulate the divine pattern in microcosm and are inherently horizontal in nature; important criteria by which marriage is ultimately to be judged traditional where Christians and most monotheists are concerned. Atheists and agnostics or other nominal or fallen-away theists who embrace traditional marriage presumably do so in a more limited sense, one in which the historical, economic and conventional aspects of heterosexual marriage (in the horizontal sense only) are desired.
There is of course a certain collective wisdom of the ages which supports so-called traditional marriage. It has not been by chance that this kind of marriage has existed as the most frequent marital arrangement in virtually all cultures and time periods. TM has many obvious advantages and arguably the fewest negatives. Pleural marriage is associated with many hardships particularly where it is illegal. Even where polygamy is legal the natural tendency toward conjugal fidelity/exclusivity which is a natural part of human anthropology is difficult if not impossible to suppress and can lead to disastrous problems associated with jealousy of one or more of the spouses for each other. Attempting to preserve an equitable relationship with multiple marriage partners would seem to be an impossible undertaking. It is truly difficult to imagine how one could honor the biblical imperative to treat their neighbor fairly under such a circumstance.
Same-sex “marriages” are perhaps the most difficult to justify philosophically. Not only is there no complementarity of the sexes, statistically there is a high incidence of non-exclusivity of homosexual partners (particularly among men) which exceeds those of heterosexuals in which the marriage is considered a civil contract only and where they are not bound by the notion of indissolubility which comes with traditional marriage through verticality (covenant). If civil contract marriages between heterosexuals are removed from divorce statistics, overall divorce rates are much lower indicating that the problem in heterosexual marriage dissolution lies in the concept of a breakable civil contract. Therefore, in the interest of the common good it would be better to limit marriage to those who intend to form a traditional marriage rather than some other “arrangement” especially same-sex ones. Heterosexual couples considering marriage would be best served by exposure to traditional marriage and all of its obvious benefits since civil contract marriages fair so poorly over the long run.
Not to be underestimated are the potential medical complications predominately among male same-sex couples due to their incompatibility anatomically. For example since anal intercourse is usually involved in male/male same sex “unions”, the columnar lined rectal epithelial mucosa which is not suitable for intercourse (the vaginal mucosa is composed of squamous epithelium and designed for intercourse) is frequently damaged predisposing it to disease including anal warts, HIV/Aids, anal gonorrhea, fissures, fistulae and incontinence etc. Corresponding pathologies are invariably seen in the male partners of those who are frequently sodomized. This should alert us to the fact that something is inherently wrong with anal intercourse (heterosexual or homosexual) even if we had no other way of knowing it—fortunately, a careful study of human anatomy and physiology coupled with an adequate grounding in Aristotelian/Thomistic moral philosophy assures that other ways of knowing do exist.
As the reader may have deduced, from the moral perspective, traditional marriage follows the general construct that the “ought” should follow the “is” meaning that the proper moral formulation should flow from the reality of being in this case the human anthropology (including anatomical complementarity and the deep desire of human beings for exclusivity) of the partners. Only if one assumes that human nature is an accident, evolving or otherwise irrelevant would the nature of human being not be of critical consideration. According to the Aristotelian/Thomistic synthesis human nature is fixed not evolving, meaning it is unchangeable by man. As a result only traditional marriage as described herein can be judged morally licit. All other so-called “arrangements” would lack one or more necessary key elements in order to be considered marriages at all, or traditional marriages in particular--including polygamist ones which are closer to traditional marriages than are those between individuals of the same sex. Despite this reality, it is noteworthy that public (political) pressure in the West is increasingly in favor of same sex “marriage” rather than polygamous ones, a fact which given the realities of human anthropology is difficult to comprehend. While neither should be legalized in the interest of the common good, polygamist “marriages” are less deranged from the perspective of the natural law than are those of a homosexual nature.
The most commonly proffered justification for same-sex “marriage” is that each human person should have the “right” (a claim advanced on society; the result of a personal choice) based on Western notions of freedom, equality and autonomy to marry anyone they wish. Given the necessary elements of traditional marriage as herein defined, it is clear that same-sex “marriage” could never be considered marriage in any meaningful sense without doing damage to the English language and thousands of years of history including that which is common to all “3” monotheistic religions presently encompassing the vast majority of global inhabitants.
In helping to focus the morality involved in non-traditional marriage some critical questions might be waged as follows;
To what extent should individuals be allowed freedom to act if those actions debase the common good and transgress established moral norms?
Only if no harm (direct or indirect) is done to other individuals and or the common good.
Do we as individuals have a moral responsibility to act personally in ways which are compatible with and enhancing of the common good?
YES.
Does personal freedom include the ability to act in ways which while not directly or immediately harmful to others are nonetheless indirectly so and eventually very injurious to the common good?
NO.
It is clearly in the common good for healthy life-long marriages between one man and one woman to be strongly encouraged if not codified in law. Moreover, it is beyond doubt in the best interest of our children to be reared in stable, two parent biological families. The sociological data strongly establish that this is the case irrespective of protestations to the contrary by those who advocate for non-traditional marriage.
Moreover, certain behaviors are not only immoral but have been made illegal as well. This is to protect individuals from injury and to insure the common good. Murder is both immoral and illegal as is rape for good reason. While homosexual activity and sexual activity with multiple sex partners is not illegal throughout the United States, it is currently illegal for multiple partners to marry (polygamy), for animals and humans to marry and in all but one state for same-sex partners to marry (Massachusetts, Editor's note: since originally written, other states have followed Mass.). The latter reality is extremely regrettable. Since homosexual behavior and sex with multiple partners is immoral and destructive of the common good, non-traditional marriage in these circumstances should remain illegal. Massachusetts should repeal its current same-sex marriage law on the grounds that it represents poor social planning where a commitment to the common good is concerned. The wishes of some individuals especially when they are violative of the natural law should not be allowed to eclipse the interest of the common good. Unfortunately, that is exactly what has transpired in the case of US laws allowing abortion on demand and destructive embryo research.
From a traditional (scholastic) moral philosophical perspective, sex with multiple partners, between humans and animals (bestiality) and between individuals of the same sex are all morally illicit. This is true because of the nature of what it means to be human (unique and fixed human anthropology) and because of the principles of the natural law (they cannot be expunged in the same way that the 4 fundamental forces of physics cannot be denied) which includes complementarity of the sexes. The record of the last half century in the United States stands as a testament to the fact that the natural moral law cannot be revoked—it is immutable. Nothing but misery comes from denying or breaking it particularly on a massive scale e.g. at the level of nation states. Those who are familiar with the so-called perennial philosophy are well aware of this reality. Obviously, those who are steeped in Modern and post-Modern philosophy find this exceedingly difficult to accept.
Therefore, a key question remains; Are non-traditional “marriage” arrangements morally licit?
No, because; they are contrary to the common good and established moral norms including those between heterosexual couples who arrange civil contract marriages. The answer is simple but not easy given post-modern confusion with respect to what constitutes truth, reality and morality. In a pluralistic secular society such as ours, it would be impossible to make heterosexual non-traditional marriages illegal (although they should be discouraged) given the nature of current civil and human rights laws. On the basis of these, proponents of same-sex marriage have made similar appeals the results of which are in flux. From the perspective of the common good of society it would clearly be best if all marriages were “traditional” in the sense utilized herein that is, both vertical and horizontal and understood as a life-long commitment between one man and one woman. The fact that this is not possible in the developed West is a testament to the disadvantageous nature of living in a pluralistic society. This negative development which can be traced to the Enlightenment is extremely regrettable.
Finally, should non-traditional marriage be legalized?
No, it is unwise public policy to legally allow behavior which is; destructive of the common good and contrary to well established moral norms. The balance between individual desires on the part of individuals and the common good is too tipped in favor of the individual to the detriment of society.
In response to my editorial comment of yesterday regarding the overturning of the California Proposition 8 ban on Gay "Marriage" several readers have asked that this essay which I penned a while back be posted again in order that they might have access to critical philosophical concepts located therein. This may be seen as a companion piece to what was posted yesterday where a link was provided to the article I wrote for the Intellectual Conservative in 2005.
What of Non-Traditional Marriage?
By: Dr. J. P. Hubert
Over the past several years marked interest has grown in what must for the sake of intellectual honesty be termed non-traditional “marriage.” By this is usually meant “civil unions” or arrangements in which same-sex couples formalize their relationship and in so doing derive the benefits usually reserved for married heterosexual couples. To date, little organized interest has been expressed for other kinds of non-traditional “marriages” such as polygamous ones or those involving animals and humans (bestiality). In any case it has now become necessary to flesh-out the philosophical implications of marriage including the nature of what it means to be a human person and what is meant by “tradition.”
As mathematician/physicist and philosopher Wolfgang Smith has taught, “traditional” when used as an adjective before anything connotes the transcendent not simply ancient or of historical significance. To say that marriage for example is traditionally a life-long commitment between one man and one woman is to say in part that it is based in the transcendent “other” which theists understand as God (being personified from a philosophical perspective); that it “embodies an element of revelation.” According to Smith, a “doctrine is traditional by virtue of the fact that it partakes somewhat of eternity.” In this sense traditional marriage is not only a horizontal but a vertical relationship (metaphysical reality) with God as one of the “partners.”
To develop this concept a bit further, traditional marriage (TM) is a microcosm/reflection of penultimate being that is, non-derivative being in much the same way that man was created in the imago Dei (image of God, Gen. 1:26). Orthodox Catholics understand it as a recapitulation of the Trinity [tri-unity (“3” who’s in one what)] that is the Blessed Trinity—wherein the “two (male and female possessing complementarity) become one flesh” (Gen. 2: 24) in the sense of giving life to a child (the third member of the human triad/family, not simply copulation between the 2 adults). From the perspective of human anthropology (nature or essence) marriage, in a traditional sense can join only one man and one woman in a permanent (covenant in religious terms) or exclusive relationship if it is to retain any semblance of meaning. As such the Traditional marriage union is a metaphysical (outside of space and time) reality as well as a physical one which is unbreakable by human means. It is this facet of traditional marriage which has been expunged in large part from post-modernity by the way.
The notion that individuals of the same sex or that multiple partners (in the sense of the simultaneous pleural marriages practiced by polygamists) could “marry” is to rob the term “traditional” marriage of any real meaning. These and other “unions” such as between humans and animals are non-traditional in the extreme. Not only do they fail to mirror in microcosm the transcendent other (GOD) as understood in Christianity, they for the most part lack complementarity (anatomically at least) as well. While pleural marriage (simultaneous or serial) on an anatomic basis may possess complementarity, it clearly lacks exclusivity. Traditional marriage then for Christians must contain the elements of complementarity and exclusivity. This is true because of the essence of what it means to be human and because traditional marriage has both a vertical and a horizontal dimension, one in space and time; one outside of or beyond it. Unfortunately, the Enlightenment, much of modern philosophy (particularly the Utilitarianism of J. S. Mill) including Cartesian Dualism followed on by Baconian notions of science including Darwinist philosophy (philosophical naturalism) have emptied traditional marriage of its true meaning. The details of these assaults on traditional marriage (TM) are beyond the scope of this short essay. However, suffice it to say that as a result of the above--human nature is no longer considered “fixed.” It is simply assumed that one can create their own nature and for that matter reality itself. This reduces marriage to a completely horizontal “arrangement” of our own making that can be undone at will--resembling something more akin to a business transaction.
Admittedly, the idea that marriage is a recapitulation of the Blessed Trinity is unique to Christianity as it is predicated on a unique and divinely revealed understanding of the nature of God. Both Judaism and Islam which either tacitly or explicitly reject the Blessed Trinity; have historically allowed simultaneous pleural marriage between human beings, (multiple wives with one husband) usually on economic, or other utilitarian grounds including custom. Nevertheless, over time, each has moved away from the practice of polygamy. It is safe to say that no monotheistic religion has endorsed non-traditional marriage between adult human beings of the same sex or between humans and animals presumably because of the issue of lack of complementarity and the recognition that traditional marriage (TM) in order to be legitimate/genuine must contain no impediment to the natural generation of children which would ensue from a lack of complementarity. This is another way of saying that marriage arrangements must not be incompatible with the Natural Law. Procreation--and with it the education and rearing of children--has traditionally been seen as either the primary/only or dual reason for marriage (along with the obvious positive unitive benefit for the spouses). Clearly this is an impossibility in the natural for same-sex and human/animal “unions.” Moreover, incest (parent/child) in recorded history has universally been sanctioned in all of the “3” monotheistic religions at least in part for reasons having to do with complications arising as a direct result of copulation and procreation (genetic disorders for example among other severe psychological problems).
While heterosexual incest is correctly ordered anatomically, it is clearly disordered from the perspective of lacking exclusivity (parents already have or should have a monogamous and exclusive relationship), genetic complications and behavioral problems. Since traditional morality holds that sexual intercourse is proper only within the bounds of marriage, it is apparent that incest could never be morally acceptable. Even in the event of death of one of the marriage partners, incest (sexual relations with one or more of the children) would be immoral on multiple other grounds including on the basis that in doing so, the remaining marriage partner would be guilty of a sin against charity with respect to the children. This would be true even if for some misguided reason the offspring were said to have given “consent.”
Some would argue that while same-sex human or opposite-sex human/animal “unions” are not marriage in the Traditional sense, pleural marriage between for example one man and multiple women should be afforded the designation “traditional marriage.” There is a certain logic to this contention in that complementarity is preserved and with it the ability to procreate. The difficulty comes in that there is no exclusivity of the partners or of their offspring for the biological parents, thus not as organically related families in these arrangements. Such “unions” fail to recapitulate the divine pattern in microcosm and are inherently horizontal in nature; important criteria by which marriage is ultimately to be judged traditional where Christians and most monotheists are concerned. Atheists and agnostics or other nominal or fallen-away theists who embrace traditional marriage presumably do so in a more limited sense, one in which the historical, economic and conventional aspects of heterosexual marriage (in the horizontal sense only) are desired.
There is of course a certain collective wisdom of the ages which supports so-called traditional marriage. It has not been by chance that this kind of marriage has existed as the most frequent marital arrangement in virtually all cultures and time periods. TM has many obvious advantages and arguably the fewest negatives. Pleural marriage is associated with many hardships particularly where it is illegal. Even where polygamy is legal the natural tendency toward conjugal fidelity/exclusivity which is a natural part of human anthropology is difficult if not impossible to suppress and can lead to disastrous problems associated with jealousy of one or more of the spouses for each other. Attempting to preserve an equitable relationship with multiple marriage partners would seem to be an impossible undertaking. It is truly difficult to imagine how one could honor the biblical imperative to treat their neighbor fairly under such a circumstance.
Same-sex “marriages” are perhaps the most difficult to justify philosophically. Not only is there no complementarity of the sexes, statistically there is a high incidence of non-exclusivity of homosexual partners (particularly among men) which exceeds those of heterosexuals in which the marriage is considered a civil contract only and where they are not bound by the notion of indissolubility which comes with traditional marriage through verticality (covenant). If civil contract marriages between heterosexuals are removed from divorce statistics, overall divorce rates are much lower indicating that the problem in heterosexual marriage dissolution lies in the concept of a breakable civil contract. Therefore, in the interest of the common good it would be better to limit marriage to those who intend to form a traditional marriage rather than some other “arrangement” especially same-sex ones. Heterosexual couples considering marriage would be best served by exposure to traditional marriage and all of its obvious benefits since civil contract marriages fair so poorly over the long run.
Not to be underestimated are the potential medical complications predominately among male same-sex couples due to their incompatibility anatomically. For example since anal intercourse is usually involved in male/male same sex “unions”, the columnar lined rectal epithelial mucosa which is not suitable for intercourse (the vaginal mucosa is composed of squamous epithelium and designed for intercourse) is frequently damaged predisposing it to disease including anal warts, HIV/Aids, anal gonorrhea, fissures, fistulae and incontinence etc. Corresponding pathologies are invariably seen in the male partners of those who are frequently sodomized. This should alert us to the fact that something is inherently wrong with anal intercourse (heterosexual or homosexual) even if we had no other way of knowing it—fortunately, a careful study of human anatomy and physiology coupled with an adequate grounding in Aristotelian/Thomistic moral philosophy assures that other ways of knowing do exist.
As the reader may have deduced, from the moral perspective, traditional marriage follows the general construct that the “ought” should follow the “is” meaning that the proper moral formulation should flow from the reality of being in this case the human anthropology (including anatomical complementarity and the deep desire of human beings for exclusivity) of the partners. Only if one assumes that human nature is an accident, evolving or otherwise irrelevant would the nature of human being not be of critical consideration. According to the Aristotelian/Thomistic synthesis human nature is fixed not evolving, meaning it is unchangeable by man. As a result only traditional marriage as described herein can be judged morally licit. All other so-called “arrangements” would lack one or more necessary key elements in order to be considered marriages at all, or traditional marriages in particular--including polygamist ones which are closer to traditional marriages than are those between individuals of the same sex. Despite this reality, it is noteworthy that public (political) pressure in the West is increasingly in favor of same sex “marriage” rather than polygamous ones, a fact which given the realities of human anthropology is difficult to comprehend. While neither should be legalized in the interest of the common good, polygamist “marriages” are less deranged from the perspective of the natural law than are those of a homosexual nature.
The most commonly proffered justification for same-sex “marriage” is that each human person should have the “right” (a claim advanced on society; the result of a personal choice) based on Western notions of freedom, equality and autonomy to marry anyone they wish. Given the necessary elements of traditional marriage as herein defined, it is clear that same-sex “marriage” could never be considered marriage in any meaningful sense without doing damage to the English language and thousands of years of history including that which is common to all “3” monotheistic religions presently encompassing the vast majority of global inhabitants.
In helping to focus the morality involved in non-traditional marriage some critical questions might be waged as follows;
To what extent should individuals be allowed freedom to act if those actions debase the common good and transgress established moral norms?
Only if no harm (direct or indirect) is done to other individuals and or the common good.
Do we as individuals have a moral responsibility to act personally in ways which are compatible with and enhancing of the common good?
YES.
Does personal freedom include the ability to act in ways which while not directly or immediately harmful to others are nonetheless indirectly so and eventually very injurious to the common good?
NO.
It is clearly in the common good for healthy life-long marriages between one man and one woman to be strongly encouraged if not codified in law. Moreover, it is beyond doubt in the best interest of our children to be reared in stable, two parent biological families. The sociological data strongly establish that this is the case irrespective of protestations to the contrary by those who advocate for non-traditional marriage.
Moreover, certain behaviors are not only immoral but have been made illegal as well. This is to protect individuals from injury and to insure the common good. Murder is both immoral and illegal as is rape for good reason. While homosexual activity and sexual activity with multiple sex partners is not illegal throughout the United States, it is currently illegal for multiple partners to marry (polygamy), for animals and humans to marry and in all but one state for same-sex partners to marry (Massachusetts, Editor's note: since originally written, other states have followed Mass.). The latter reality is extremely regrettable. Since homosexual behavior and sex with multiple partners is immoral and destructive of the common good, non-traditional marriage in these circumstances should remain illegal. Massachusetts should repeal its current same-sex marriage law on the grounds that it represents poor social planning where a commitment to the common good is concerned. The wishes of some individuals especially when they are violative of the natural law should not be allowed to eclipse the interest of the common good. Unfortunately, that is exactly what has transpired in the case of US laws allowing abortion on demand and destructive embryo research.
From a traditional (scholastic) moral philosophical perspective, sex with multiple partners, between humans and animals (bestiality) and between individuals of the same sex are all morally illicit. This is true because of the nature of what it means to be human (unique and fixed human anthropology) and because of the principles of the natural law (they cannot be expunged in the same way that the 4 fundamental forces of physics cannot be denied) which includes complementarity of the sexes. The record of the last half century in the United States stands as a testament to the fact that the natural moral law cannot be revoked—it is immutable. Nothing but misery comes from denying or breaking it particularly on a massive scale e.g. at the level of nation states. Those who are familiar with the so-called perennial philosophy are well aware of this reality. Obviously, those who are steeped in Modern and post-Modern philosophy find this exceedingly difficult to accept.
Therefore, a key question remains; Are non-traditional “marriage” arrangements morally licit?
No, because; they are contrary to the common good and established moral norms including those between heterosexual couples who arrange civil contract marriages. The answer is simple but not easy given post-modern confusion with respect to what constitutes truth, reality and morality. In a pluralistic secular society such as ours, it would be impossible to make heterosexual non-traditional marriages illegal (although they should be discouraged) given the nature of current civil and human rights laws. On the basis of these, proponents of same-sex marriage have made similar appeals the results of which are in flux. From the perspective of the common good of society it would clearly be best if all marriages were “traditional” in the sense utilized herein that is, both vertical and horizontal and understood as a life-long commitment between one man and one woman. The fact that this is not possible in the developed West is a testament to the disadvantageous nature of living in a pluralistic society. This negative development which can be traced to the Enlightenment is extremely regrettable.
Finally, should non-traditional marriage be legalized?
No, it is unwise public policy to legally allow behavior which is; destructive of the common good and contrary to well established moral norms. The balance between individual desires on the part of individuals and the common good is too tipped in favor of the individual to the detriment of society.
Thursday, August 5, 2010
The Problem with Gay “Marriage” Bans
Editorial Comment by Dr. J. P. Hubert
The ruling yesterday by Judge Vaughn Walker in which he overturned California’s Proposition 8 banning homosexual “Marriage” is but another in the long line of those being issued by an American Judicial system steeped in Legal Positivism (Pragmatism). As I wrote several years ago for the Intellectual Conservative, December 2005 in “The ‘Fruits’ of Legal Positivism: Utilitarianism in Action”:
“For over 60 years, the United States Supreme Court has progressively departed from what was primarily a Natural Law based understanding of its role in constitutional interpretation…That construct utilized the constitution as written, relying on the so-called original intent or a strict constructionist interpretation as a template upon which the tenets of the Natural Law were traced. For almost 100 years, the USSC has embraced Legal Positivism, in which no immutable moral principles are recognized, including the first and second principles of the Natural Law (do good/ avoid evil and treat your neighbor fairly).
…The only unifying principle allowed to permeate legal positivism is personal autonomy or choice, itself an expression of ‘survival of the fittest’ (read selfishness) which has become the new judicial rallying cry. Thus it follows that virtually any new social/cultural experiment can be codified into law by the Supreme Court even if such a law could never be passed by the representatives of the people who still adhere largely to the principles of the Natural Law and the Judeo-Christian Ethic (e.g. Proposition 8 banning homosexual “marriage”). Why? Because the court is simply not restrained or controlled by the observance of any moral absolutes.
…Legal Positivism or pragmatism -- developed by Oliver Wendell Holmes and those who followed… is based entirely on a Secularist worldview in which the controlling moral philosophy is utilitarian… American Jurisprudence is now held hostage to an alien judicial philosophy based not on the Natural Law or the Judeo-Christian ethic, but rather on the post-Enlightenment philosophies of Mill, Hume, Rousseau, Locke, Hobbes and Darwin.
Legal Positivism reduced to the lowest common denominator is the application of Darwinian Natural Selection (survival of the fittest) to a constantly changing moral code based on personal preference or “choice” in the realm of the civil law. Under this rubric, moral absolutes do not really exist, since morality in general is determined by what is socially acceptable at a given period of time in history…
…it is assumed that if Congress passes a law, the USSC has the right to determine whether it is constitutional and morally permissible, as if the two were synonymous. It is simply presumed a priori that nothing which the court could declare constitutional for whatever reason could ever be immoral, despite obvious examples to the contrary. The entire process becomes an exercise in debate over second order questions without any first order foundation. Put differently, there is no transcendent -- in the metaphysical sense -- referent by which the moral licitness of a given law can be compared. Laws become whatever society at a given point in history wants them to be. The function of the Supreme Court then becomes one of “divining” what Americans presently think, feel or want, what common assumptions they have become accustomed to making and so on. Then a majority of Justices create a way or tactic -- whether logically coherent or not - -to justify the conclusion which they have already made. In the process, to a greater or lesser degree they attempt to demonstrate how the Constitution actually contains the warrant for their findings.
…the moral licitness of any law is a totally separate question from whether it is constitutional; irrespective of whether it is or is not consistent with “original constitutional intent.” The original intent of a given law may always have been morally illicit from the perspective of the Natural Law, the Judeo-Christian Ethic, and the common morality. It may even have been immoral by virtue of any other applicable moral philosophy -- even utilitarianism. For example, slavery was arguably immoral by the Natural Law/Judeo-Christian Ethic, but yet was not originally considered unconstitutional. It is difficult today for most people to believe that African-Americans were once considered property. Slavery was codified in law, however, because even from the beginning of the American experiment, the civil law was not based entirely on the Natural Law. Utilitarian moral thinking began very early to insinuate its way from the Continent into the colonial experience.
We are left to believe, according to the tenets of legal positivism, that during the period in question, slavery was permissible and constitutional because it was commonly accepted, economically based and people were accustomed to it. At a later date, the “situation” changed and a different set of assumptions obtained. It also means that if in the future it becomes expedient for slavery to once again exist, the Supreme Court could again reverse itself and legalize slavery based on race, religion, class or any other criterion thought to be of utility. The reason this is so is that there are no absolute moral proscriptions which undergird the civil law according to the rubrics of legal positivism…
…It is simply moronic to believe that constitutional law exists without a pre-philosophy, a set of fundamental assumptions or overarching principle(s). Every discipline has a set of so-called pre-philosophical assumptions, also known as first-order philosophical questions/presumptions. For example, the question of what the law is in a metaphysical sense actually involves a first order philosophical question and is not a legal question at all. Every Senator who serves as an interlocutor on the Judiciary Committee and each USSC nominee who appears in the confirmation process have a “pre-philosophy” with regard to what the civil law should be grounded in, as well as a specific judicial/constitutional philosophy (e.g. original intent vs: an evolving constitutional standard). It unfortunately has become acceptable to simply deny this (as Judge John Roberts did at his confirmation hearing), as if the Supreme Court is able to divine the proper ruling virtually out of “thin air” without regard to first principles.
Social Darwinism Replaces Transcendent Truths
What we have done then as a culture over the past half century is to codify in the civil law, a legal system which is not only productive of illogical and contradictory rulings, but one which is totally arbitrary and grounded in the principles of social Darwinism rather than immutable truths. Decades ago it was incumbent upon those who understood -- that the USSC was attempting to radically alter the moral philosophical basis which had been foundational to the U.S. constitutional system -- to rise up and object in the strongest terms rather than remaining mute by “playing the game.” Had this been done in the mid-twentieth century, the present deceptive system for confirming a Supreme Court Justice would not exist. The result of failing to do so has meant that the entire process is now nothing more than a pretense in which interested candidates must either actively or passively agree to be involved in evil as a means to the potentially good end of being placed on the Supreme Court, the very definition of Utilitarianism. Such a circumstance is incompatible with the truth that should be at the foundational center of justice and is not simply a matter of the Supreme Court legislating from the bench. Legislating by the rule of the majority in a way which is contrary to the Natural Law is also immoral. Rather than fairness, consistency and equality before the law, the present system is capricious and inherently unjust. It typifies a “might makes right” mentality achieved either through a tyranny of the majority at the ballot box, the appellate court or Supreme Court level as demonstrated in 5-4 decisions. Truth is the very last thing which is served under such a system and once truth is sacrificed at the alter of expediency, justice is vacated as well.
With respect to the USSC, the issue is not judicial activism alone (the court usurping the role of the legislature), nor is it a failure to adhere to stare decisis, original intent or a Strict Constructionist methodology. It is the failure of both the legislative and the judicial branches (but especially the USSC) to adhere to the immutable principles of the Natural Law as codified in the Judeo-Christian Ethic. Until this issue can be discussed vis-a-vis the foundational philosophical problem that it is; rather than the straw man indictment which labels it “a private or deeply held religious belief,” our laws will remain unjust and no one in America will be safe from tyranny. The fact that our laws are no longer based on the common morality which flows from the Natural Law as historically contained in the Judeo-Christian ethic [and later common law] is ultimately a philosophical not fundamentally religious problem. Once this is widely recognized we can then make progress in reforming the U. S. Supreme Court, something all true conservatives should be interested in.” read original article HERE…
No Agreement on Right and Wrong:
A ban such as California's Proposition 8 on homosexual “marriage” presupposes of course that the question is a judicial or elective one rather than foundationally a moral philosophical one. Even more fundamentally; by what set of criteria are Americans to judge the moral licitness of issues of public policy? In contemporary America there are none. In fact there is absolutely no agreement at all among the ruling class in the United States about what is morally right or wrong. These kinds of questions are simply never addressed. With the elite's use of the Hegelian dialectic in which the populace is being force-fed a lethal dose of right/left diatribes by the corporate fawning media, there would be too much polarization for there ever to be agreement on societal moral (immutable) norms.
Human Nature is Fixed:
Rather than utilizing a natural law based paradigm in which human anthropology is assumed to be fixed and in which the “ought” (of moral philosophical questions) becomes necessarily circumscribed by the “is” of human nature, legal pragmatism assumes that human nature is elastic, that there are no immutable moral norms and that moral questions are really not moral in any actual sense at all. This is the sine-qua-non of utilitarian legal pragmatism. From the perspective of legal pragmatism, the first order question of how one determines right or wrong is simply irrelevant. Most Americans would be surprised to find out that while they must live as if there were fixed moral norms the legislature and the judiciary do not.
According to the Utilitarian calculus undergirding the legal pragmatism currently in vogue, the judiciary and the legislative avenues exist to normalize/sanction whatever behavior is desired by a suitably powerful subset of the populace. At the present time, it is popular to normalize personal behaviors which are contrary to the natural moral law only because a powerful vocal minority of Americans wishes that to be the case. Under this rubric questions of right and wrong reduce to the vocalized desires of politically powerful interest groups which of course change from time to time and place to place.
What About the Common Good?:
The argument which appears to have won the day is that it is unfair or unjust for some persons to be able to derive the benefits of the married state and not others simply because of their personal sexual habits/preferences. It is not enough that individuals are allowed to behave in virtually any way they desire in the privacy of their own homes even if doing so is contrary to the natural moral law--which is nevertheless legal. No consideration has been given to the ways in which the common good of society will or will not be affected by the broad legalization of gay “marriage.” Advocates cite the short-term absence of social problems since gay marriages were first allowed in California as if long-term follow-up data is unnecessary in adequately evaluating the results.
What are the Goods of Marriage?:
No discussion has ensued regarding what the "goods" of marriage actually are--the primary purpose of which is the producing and rearing of children--or the sociological data which establishes that children are best raised in 2 heterosexual parent families. Obviously the fact that the US allows divorce on demand suggests that the primary purpose of marriage was not considered in fashioning contemporary divorce laws. For similar reasons, there is a movement to normalize childhood adoption by homosexual couples and single adults. This is in contradistinction to the fact that society has a vested interest in ensuring that the common good is enhanced.
What is in a Word?/Utopian Disreality:
Homosexual "marriage" and adoption is inherently incapable of contributing to the common good as that term has been traditionally used due to the incompatibility (lack of complementarity) which exists in the human nature's of same-sex couples. While various legal "arrangements" can be entered into by same-sex couples as they admittedly are by heterosexuals who contract civil (non-covenant) marriages, they can never be marriages in the traditional (where marriage symbolizes the coming together of male and female to produce another, the triad of which represents an image of the Sacred Trinity) sense where anatomic, physiologic and genetic factors are prerequisites. To arbitrarily define them as such in the law is to deny the very nature of what it means to be human, male and female. This reality will seem harsh to many but epistemologically it is undeniable.
Advocates of same-sex "marriage" if honest will be forced to admit that they desire to engage in such "arrangements" despite the inherent dis-reality involved. Doing so is to engage in positing a false reality, a utopian metaphysical unreality if you will, a worldview based not on the truth of what is but on the falsehood of what is not. In that regard the USSC (e.g. Justice Kennedy) has written essentially that each citizen is entitled to establish their own reality as if a human being has the power to determine metaphysical truths anymore than those of a physical nature as determined by universal physical laws. No one would posit the latter, but the former is currently being advanced by the USSC. The fact that Justice Kennedy was not harangued by the academic establishment for positing such an irrational concept should suffice to document that legal pragmatism has overtaken the US judiciary at least at the level of the USSC.
The American judiciary utilizing the theory of legal pragmatism is engaged in making legal what is proscribed by the natural moral law in so doing hoping to alter the “common morality” in such a way as to baptize it as if its advocates embraced the natural moral law and the notion of immutable moral norms which they of course do not. This is hypocrisy of the first order (first deny the natural moral law and once the civil law is changed behave as if it exists since whatever is legal is assumed to be moral).
What is the Ultimate Limit?:
Why should anyone believe that homosexual “marriage” is any more acceptable than any other currently illegal and immoral practice such as polygamy, pedophilia, pederasty, bestiality? Surely there are a not negligible number of individuals who desire to partake in these activities based on the crime statistics which are available--and with the marked deterioration in moral climate in the West there are likely to be more not less as time marches on. All of these practices however are contrary to the natural moral law as is homosexual practice and
homosexual “marriage.” Can we not assume that an equally powerful subset of our population will eventually advocate for the changing of these laws as well, and on what basis could it be denied if individuals came forward who wished to engage in these activities, label them marriage and derive marital benefits. According to the judicial theory of legal pragmatism any of these are worthy of being made legal for the exact same reasons being utilized to justify gay “marriage.”
The reality is that Americans simply refuse to engage in a debate about how to determine right and wrong. The unstated reality is that if a practice or behavior can be made legal, it is immaterial whether it violates the natural moral law or the wishes and belief structure of a majority of citizens. All that matters is that the special interest group who desires the change is satisfied. We prefer to settle all such issues by making laws which either allow or disallow certain practices based upon the exercise of raw political power alone. This is a formula for endless discord and polarization as nothing is ever definitively settled. It is nothing more that “might makes right” a form of judicially insured tyranny.
California’s Proposition 8 is an attempt to solve what is ultimately a moral philosophical problem through the use of the ballot box and the courts. The current trajectory is that homosexual marriage will eventually be legalized in all 50 states and codified in federal law. Given that the judiciary has embraced legal pragmatism, no other outcome is logically possible and therin lies the problem for opponents of gay "marriage." Americans wishing to prevent it will need to wage the battle where it actually belongs on the level of morality, a return to natural law based jurisprudence and not the law as understood through the prism of legal pragmatism. Unfortunately, that ground was surrendered long ago.
The ruling yesterday by Judge Vaughn Walker in which he overturned California’s Proposition 8 banning homosexual “Marriage” is but another in the long line of those being issued by an American Judicial system steeped in Legal Positivism (Pragmatism). As I wrote several years ago for the Intellectual Conservative, December 2005 in “The ‘Fruits’ of Legal Positivism: Utilitarianism in Action”:
“For over 60 years, the United States Supreme Court has progressively departed from what was primarily a Natural Law based understanding of its role in constitutional interpretation…That construct utilized the constitution as written, relying on the so-called original intent or a strict constructionist interpretation as a template upon which the tenets of the Natural Law were traced. For almost 100 years, the USSC has embraced Legal Positivism, in which no immutable moral principles are recognized, including the first and second principles of the Natural Law (do good/ avoid evil and treat your neighbor fairly).
…The only unifying principle allowed to permeate legal positivism is personal autonomy or choice, itself an expression of ‘survival of the fittest’ (read selfishness) which has become the new judicial rallying cry. Thus it follows that virtually any new social/cultural experiment can be codified into law by the Supreme Court even if such a law could never be passed by the representatives of the people who still adhere largely to the principles of the Natural Law and the Judeo-Christian Ethic (e.g. Proposition 8 banning homosexual “marriage”). Why? Because the court is simply not restrained or controlled by the observance of any moral absolutes.
…Legal Positivism or pragmatism -- developed by Oliver Wendell Holmes and those who followed… is based entirely on a Secularist worldview in which the controlling moral philosophy is utilitarian… American Jurisprudence is now held hostage to an alien judicial philosophy based not on the Natural Law or the Judeo-Christian ethic, but rather on the post-Enlightenment philosophies of Mill, Hume, Rousseau, Locke, Hobbes and Darwin.
Legal Positivism reduced to the lowest common denominator is the application of Darwinian Natural Selection (survival of the fittest) to a constantly changing moral code based on personal preference or “choice” in the realm of the civil law. Under this rubric, moral absolutes do not really exist, since morality in general is determined by what is socially acceptable at a given period of time in history…
…it is assumed that if Congress passes a law, the USSC has the right to determine whether it is constitutional and morally permissible, as if the two were synonymous. It is simply presumed a priori that nothing which the court could declare constitutional for whatever reason could ever be immoral, despite obvious examples to the contrary. The entire process becomes an exercise in debate over second order questions without any first order foundation. Put differently, there is no transcendent -- in the metaphysical sense -- referent by which the moral licitness of a given law can be compared. Laws become whatever society at a given point in history wants them to be. The function of the Supreme Court then becomes one of “divining” what Americans presently think, feel or want, what common assumptions they have become accustomed to making and so on. Then a majority of Justices create a way or tactic -- whether logically coherent or not - -to justify the conclusion which they have already made. In the process, to a greater or lesser degree they attempt to demonstrate how the Constitution actually contains the warrant for their findings.
…the moral licitness of any law is a totally separate question from whether it is constitutional; irrespective of whether it is or is not consistent with “original constitutional intent.” The original intent of a given law may always have been morally illicit from the perspective of the Natural Law, the Judeo-Christian Ethic, and the common morality. It may even have been immoral by virtue of any other applicable moral philosophy -- even utilitarianism. For example, slavery was arguably immoral by the Natural Law/Judeo-Christian Ethic, but yet was not originally considered unconstitutional. It is difficult today for most people to believe that African-Americans were once considered property. Slavery was codified in law, however, because even from the beginning of the American experiment, the civil law was not based entirely on the Natural Law. Utilitarian moral thinking began very early to insinuate its way from the Continent into the colonial experience.
We are left to believe, according to the tenets of legal positivism, that during the period in question, slavery was permissible and constitutional because it was commonly accepted, economically based and people were accustomed to it. At a later date, the “situation” changed and a different set of assumptions obtained. It also means that if in the future it becomes expedient for slavery to once again exist, the Supreme Court could again reverse itself and legalize slavery based on race, religion, class or any other criterion thought to be of utility. The reason this is so is that there are no absolute moral proscriptions which undergird the civil law according to the rubrics of legal positivism…
…It is simply moronic to believe that constitutional law exists without a pre-philosophy, a set of fundamental assumptions or overarching principle(s). Every discipline has a set of so-called pre-philosophical assumptions, also known as first-order philosophical questions/presumptions. For example, the question of what the law is in a metaphysical sense actually involves a first order philosophical question and is not a legal question at all. Every Senator who serves as an interlocutor on the Judiciary Committee and each USSC nominee who appears in the confirmation process have a “pre-philosophy” with regard to what the civil law should be grounded in, as well as a specific judicial/constitutional philosophy (e.g. original intent vs: an evolving constitutional standard). It unfortunately has become acceptable to simply deny this (as Judge John Roberts did at his confirmation hearing), as if the Supreme Court is able to divine the proper ruling virtually out of “thin air” without regard to first principles.
Social Darwinism Replaces Transcendent Truths
What we have done then as a culture over the past half century is to codify in the civil law, a legal system which is not only productive of illogical and contradictory rulings, but one which is totally arbitrary and grounded in the principles of social Darwinism rather than immutable truths. Decades ago it was incumbent upon those who understood -- that the USSC was attempting to radically alter the moral philosophical basis which had been foundational to the U.S. constitutional system -- to rise up and object in the strongest terms rather than remaining mute by “playing the game.” Had this been done in the mid-twentieth century, the present deceptive system for confirming a Supreme Court Justice would not exist. The result of failing to do so has meant that the entire process is now nothing more than a pretense in which interested candidates must either actively or passively agree to be involved in evil as a means to the potentially good end of being placed on the Supreme Court, the very definition of Utilitarianism. Such a circumstance is incompatible with the truth that should be at the foundational center of justice and is not simply a matter of the Supreme Court legislating from the bench. Legislating by the rule of the majority in a way which is contrary to the Natural Law is also immoral. Rather than fairness, consistency and equality before the law, the present system is capricious and inherently unjust. It typifies a “might makes right” mentality achieved either through a tyranny of the majority at the ballot box, the appellate court or Supreme Court level as demonstrated in 5-4 decisions. Truth is the very last thing which is served under such a system and once truth is sacrificed at the alter of expediency, justice is vacated as well.
With respect to the USSC, the issue is not judicial activism alone (the court usurping the role of the legislature), nor is it a failure to adhere to stare decisis, original intent or a Strict Constructionist methodology. It is the failure of both the legislative and the judicial branches (but especially the USSC) to adhere to the immutable principles of the Natural Law as codified in the Judeo-Christian Ethic. Until this issue can be discussed vis-a-vis the foundational philosophical problem that it is; rather than the straw man indictment which labels it “a private or deeply held religious belief,” our laws will remain unjust and no one in America will be safe from tyranny. The fact that our laws are no longer based on the common morality which flows from the Natural Law as historically contained in the Judeo-Christian ethic [and later common law] is ultimately a philosophical not fundamentally religious problem. Once this is widely recognized we can then make progress in reforming the U. S. Supreme Court, something all true conservatives should be interested in.” read original article HERE…
No Agreement on Right and Wrong:
A ban such as California's Proposition 8 on homosexual “marriage” presupposes of course that the question is a judicial or elective one rather than foundationally a moral philosophical one. Even more fundamentally; by what set of criteria are Americans to judge the moral licitness of issues of public policy? In contemporary America there are none. In fact there is absolutely no agreement at all among the ruling class in the United States about what is morally right or wrong. These kinds of questions are simply never addressed. With the elite's use of the Hegelian dialectic in which the populace is being force-fed a lethal dose of right/left diatribes by the corporate fawning media, there would be too much polarization for there ever to be agreement on societal moral (immutable) norms.
Human Nature is Fixed:
Rather than utilizing a natural law based paradigm in which human anthropology is assumed to be fixed and in which the “ought” (of moral philosophical questions) becomes necessarily circumscribed by the “is” of human nature, legal pragmatism assumes that human nature is elastic, that there are no immutable moral norms and that moral questions are really not moral in any actual sense at all. This is the sine-qua-non of utilitarian legal pragmatism. From the perspective of legal pragmatism, the first order question of how one determines right or wrong is simply irrelevant. Most Americans would be surprised to find out that while they must live as if there were fixed moral norms the legislature and the judiciary do not.
According to the Utilitarian calculus undergirding the legal pragmatism currently in vogue, the judiciary and the legislative avenues exist to normalize/sanction whatever behavior is desired by a suitably powerful subset of the populace. At the present time, it is popular to normalize personal behaviors which are contrary to the natural moral law only because a powerful vocal minority of Americans wishes that to be the case. Under this rubric questions of right and wrong reduce to the vocalized desires of politically powerful interest groups which of course change from time to time and place to place.
What About the Common Good?:
The argument which appears to have won the day is that it is unfair or unjust for some persons to be able to derive the benefits of the married state and not others simply because of their personal sexual habits/preferences. It is not enough that individuals are allowed to behave in virtually any way they desire in the privacy of their own homes even if doing so is contrary to the natural moral law--which is nevertheless legal. No consideration has been given to the ways in which the common good of society will or will not be affected by the broad legalization of gay “marriage.” Advocates cite the short-term absence of social problems since gay marriages were first allowed in California as if long-term follow-up data is unnecessary in adequately evaluating the results.
What are the Goods of Marriage?:
No discussion has ensued regarding what the "goods" of marriage actually are--the primary purpose of which is the producing and rearing of children--or the sociological data which establishes that children are best raised in 2 heterosexual parent families. Obviously the fact that the US allows divorce on demand suggests that the primary purpose of marriage was not considered in fashioning contemporary divorce laws. For similar reasons, there is a movement to normalize childhood adoption by homosexual couples and single adults. This is in contradistinction to the fact that society has a vested interest in ensuring that the common good is enhanced.
What is in a Word?/Utopian Disreality:
Homosexual "marriage" and adoption is inherently incapable of contributing to the common good as that term has been traditionally used due to the incompatibility (lack of complementarity) which exists in the human nature's of same-sex couples. While various legal "arrangements" can be entered into by same-sex couples as they admittedly are by heterosexuals who contract civil (non-covenant) marriages, they can never be marriages in the traditional (where marriage symbolizes the coming together of male and female to produce another, the triad of which represents an image of the Sacred Trinity) sense where anatomic, physiologic and genetic factors are prerequisites. To arbitrarily define them as such in the law is to deny the very nature of what it means to be human, male and female. This reality will seem harsh to many but epistemologically it is undeniable.
Advocates of same-sex "marriage" if honest will be forced to admit that they desire to engage in such "arrangements" despite the inherent dis-reality involved. Doing so is to engage in positing a false reality, a utopian metaphysical unreality if you will, a worldview based not on the truth of what is but on the falsehood of what is not. In that regard the USSC (e.g. Justice Kennedy) has written essentially that each citizen is entitled to establish their own reality as if a human being has the power to determine metaphysical truths anymore than those of a physical nature as determined by universal physical laws. No one would posit the latter, but the former is currently being advanced by the USSC. The fact that Justice Kennedy was not harangued by the academic establishment for positing such an irrational concept should suffice to document that legal pragmatism has overtaken the US judiciary at least at the level of the USSC.
The American judiciary utilizing the theory of legal pragmatism is engaged in making legal what is proscribed by the natural moral law in so doing hoping to alter the “common morality” in such a way as to baptize it as if its advocates embraced the natural moral law and the notion of immutable moral norms which they of course do not. This is hypocrisy of the first order (first deny the natural moral law and once the civil law is changed behave as if it exists since whatever is legal is assumed to be moral).
What is the Ultimate Limit?:
Why should anyone believe that homosexual “marriage” is any more acceptable than any other currently illegal and immoral practice such as polygamy, pedophilia, pederasty, bestiality? Surely there are a not negligible number of individuals who desire to partake in these activities based on the crime statistics which are available--and with the marked deterioration in moral climate in the West there are likely to be more not less as time marches on. All of these practices however are contrary to the natural moral law as is homosexual practice and
homosexual “marriage.” Can we not assume that an equally powerful subset of our population will eventually advocate for the changing of these laws as well, and on what basis could it be denied if individuals came forward who wished to engage in these activities, label them marriage and derive marital benefits. According to the judicial theory of legal pragmatism any of these are worthy of being made legal for the exact same reasons being utilized to justify gay “marriage.”
The reality is that Americans simply refuse to engage in a debate about how to determine right and wrong. The unstated reality is that if a practice or behavior can be made legal, it is immaterial whether it violates the natural moral law or the wishes and belief structure of a majority of citizens. All that matters is that the special interest group who desires the change is satisfied. We prefer to settle all such issues by making laws which either allow or disallow certain practices based upon the exercise of raw political power alone. This is a formula for endless discord and polarization as nothing is ever definitively settled. It is nothing more that “might makes right” a form of judicially insured tyranny.
California’s Proposition 8 is an attempt to solve what is ultimately a moral philosophical problem through the use of the ballot box and the courts. The current trajectory is that homosexual marriage will eventually be legalized in all 50 states and codified in federal law. Given that the judiciary has embraced legal pragmatism, no other outcome is logically possible and therin lies the problem for opponents of gay "marriage." Americans wishing to prevent it will need to wage the battle where it actually belongs on the level of morality, a return to natural law based jurisprudence and not the law as understood through the prism of legal pragmatism. Unfortunately, that ground was surrendered long ago.
Saturday, November 28, 2009
Sodom in the nation's capital
There is a centrality of the traditional family to the American dream of opportunity and a centrality of family breakdown to poverty.
By Star Parker
Speroforum.com
Monday, November 23, 2009
At a time when our country is sick, it shouldn't surprise that one our sickest places is our nation's capital. The poverty rate of Washington, DC, almost 20 percent, is one of the highest in the nation. Its child poverty rate is the nation's highest..
DC's public school system, with a graduation rate of less than 50 percent, is one of the worst in the country.
According to DC's HIV/AIDS office, three percent of the local population has HIV or AIDS. The Administrator of this office notes that this HIV/AIDS incidence is "...higher than West Africa...on par with Uganda and some parts of Kenya." And the principal way that HIV is transmitted continues to be through male homosexual activity.
Amidst this dismal picture, the DC City Council, perhaps on the theory that serving up another glass of wine is the way to help a drunk, is scheduled to vote on December 1 to legalize same sex marriage in America's capital city.
Looking at realities in Washington, DC should make clear why George Washington said "Of all the dispositions and habits which lead to political prosperity, religion and morality are indispensable supports."
But the America that our first president had in mind was very different from the vision of our DC government officials.
George Washington's America was one in which the point of freedom is to allow Man to rise to what he can become. To do this, the greatest challenge he faces is conquering himself. To rise above his baser instincts, to rise above the many temptations that lead him astray. And to achieve this end, as Washington said, "religion and morality are indispensable supports."
In left wing America, of which the DC government is a poster child, freedom means to indulge every instinct that the tradition and religion of George Washington would have us overcome.
Where does it lead? Well, look at DC.
It is tempting to look at DC's realities and just call this a black thing. And by and large it is.
DC is largely black -- almost 60 percent. Its poverty is black poverty. Its public school system serves mostly black children. And its AIDS crisis is mostly among blacks.
But the pathologies that strike the weakest parts of our population most brutally are nonetheless pathologies of the nation.
The Brooking's Institution is one of our oldest policy institutes and certainly no bastion of conservatism. But in a recently published volume, Brooking's scholars Ron Haskins and Isabel Sawhill point out the centrality of the traditional family to the American dream of opportunity and the centrality of family breakdown to poverty.
Reporting data showing the general breakdown of the traditional American family, they say, "'Some claim that anyone who is concerned about these trends is simply out of touch with modern culture'; we respond that, if that be the case, then, 'modern culture is out of touch with the needs of children.'"
The Catholic Archdiocese of DC announced that legalization of same sex marriage would make it impossible to continue its relationship with the DC government and require termination of the social services it provides to some 68,000 of the city's poor -- including about one third of its homeless. The reaction of DC council member David Catania was essentially "so what." According to him, "their services are not indispensable."
Is Catania out of touch with the needs of DC's poor?
No. He just has different priorities. More important to him, and more important to DC's left wing city council, is advancing moral relativism and the indulgences it feeds.
This is more important to them than feeding the poor or recognizing the values that would get them out of poverty.
It should concern every American as we watch our nation's capital city transform officially into Sodom.
By Star Parker
Speroforum.com
Monday, November 23, 2009
At a time when our country is sick, it shouldn't surprise that one our sickest places is our nation's capital. The poverty rate of Washington, DC, almost 20 percent, is one of the highest in the nation. Its child poverty rate is the nation's highest..
DC's public school system, with a graduation rate of less than 50 percent, is one of the worst in the country.
According to DC's HIV/AIDS office, three percent of the local population has HIV or AIDS. The Administrator of this office notes that this HIV/AIDS incidence is "...higher than West Africa...on par with Uganda and some parts of Kenya." And the principal way that HIV is transmitted continues to be through male homosexual activity.
Amidst this dismal picture, the DC City Council, perhaps on the theory that serving up another glass of wine is the way to help a drunk, is scheduled to vote on December 1 to legalize same sex marriage in America's capital city.
Looking at realities in Washington, DC should make clear why George Washington said "Of all the dispositions and habits which lead to political prosperity, religion and morality are indispensable supports."
But the America that our first president had in mind was very different from the vision of our DC government officials.
George Washington's America was one in which the point of freedom is to allow Man to rise to what he can become. To do this, the greatest challenge he faces is conquering himself. To rise above his baser instincts, to rise above the many temptations that lead him astray. And to achieve this end, as Washington said, "religion and morality are indispensable supports."
In left wing America, of which the DC government is a poster child, freedom means to indulge every instinct that the tradition and religion of George Washington would have us overcome.
Where does it lead? Well, look at DC.
It is tempting to look at DC's realities and just call this a black thing. And by and large it is.
DC is largely black -- almost 60 percent. Its poverty is black poverty. Its public school system serves mostly black children. And its AIDS crisis is mostly among blacks.
But the pathologies that strike the weakest parts of our population most brutally are nonetheless pathologies of the nation.
The Brooking's Institution is one of our oldest policy institutes and certainly no bastion of conservatism. But in a recently published volume, Brooking's scholars Ron Haskins and Isabel Sawhill point out the centrality of the traditional family to the American dream of opportunity and the centrality of family breakdown to poverty.
Reporting data showing the general breakdown of the traditional American family, they say, "'Some claim that anyone who is concerned about these trends is simply out of touch with modern culture'; we respond that, if that be the case, then, 'modern culture is out of touch with the needs of children.'"
The Catholic Archdiocese of DC announced that legalization of same sex marriage would make it impossible to continue its relationship with the DC government and require termination of the social services it provides to some 68,000 of the city's poor -- including about one third of its homeless. The reaction of DC council member David Catania was essentially "so what." According to him, "their services are not indispensable."
Is Catania out of touch with the needs of DC's poor?
No. He just has different priorities. More important to him, and more important to DC's left wing city council, is advancing moral relativism and the indulgences it feeds.
This is more important to them than feeding the poor or recognizing the values that would get them out of poverty.
It should concern every American as we watch our nation's capital city transform officially into Sodom.
Monday, October 12, 2009
Making a Federal Case for Gay Rights March Pushes Marital, Military Equality
By Nelson Hernandez and Yamiche Alcindor
Washington Post Staff Writers
Monday, October 12, 2009

Tens of thousands of gay-rights activists marched Sunday in Washington to show President Obama and Congress that they are impatient with what they consider piecemeal progress and are ready to fight at the federal level for across-the-board equality, including for the right to marry and the right to serve in the military.
Key votes on same-sex marriage are coming up in the District and Maine, and Obama reiterated his campaign promise Saturday to end the "don't ask, don't tell" policy that forces gay and lesbian members of the armed forces to keep their sexual orientation a secret.
But organizers of the National Equality March and its participants said they want to shift the political effort toward seeking equality in all states, rather than accepting just local and state-level victories.
"We're not settling," said Cleve Jones, co-chairman of the march and founder of the Names Project, the AIDS memorial quilt that recognizes Americans who have died from HIV- or AIDS-related causes. "There's no such thing as a fraction of equality. We want equal protection under the law."
The march was coordinated by Equality Across America, a group formed this year. Organizers said they represent those who want immediate fundamental change in the legal status of gays, as opposed to those who think patience is needed as legal obstacles are overcome.
Some in the latter group are political veterans, such as Rep. Barney Frank (D-Mass.), the highest-ranking openly gay political figure in the United States. Last week, Frank said he thought the march was "useless," a remark that was attacked at the rally.
"How many more tears should be shed before some politicians in a backroom can decide it is convenient to join us and fight for our freedom?" asked David Mixner, a longtime activist who spoke at the rally.
Attendees expressed complicated feelings about Obama. Nearly every person interviewed said he or she had voted for him, but many people said they were disappointed by what they see as a lack of action on key gay-rights issues, such as letting gays serve openly in the military.
Thousands of people marched from McPherson Square, a few blocks from the White House, down Pennsylvania Avenue, chanting "President Obama: Let mama marry mama!" and "L, G, B, T -- We demand equality!"
Marchers carried signs reading "We Won't Wait for Full Equality" and "Mind Your Own Marriage." Spectators watched from the street and the roof of the Newseum, many cheering the participants. As the march ended about 2:30 p.m., people gathered on Capitol Hill for a rally.
Many supporters identified themselves as heterosexual, carrying signs with such slogans as "I'm Not Queer But I'm Here."
"They told me that you didn't care and you wouldn't come," Mixner told the crowd. "The president asked us to help him, and help him we will."
The march occurred at a critical time for the gay-rights movement, with a president who has vowed to fight for equality and Democrats in control of Congress.
Obama pledged Saturday night at a fundraising dinner for the Human Rights Campaign that he would end the military's "don't ask, don't tell" policy, but he provided no specifics on how. Many gay activists said that they are tired of waiting and that he should immediately move to repeal the military's policy and the Defense of Marriage Act.
Sue Null, 72, walked near the White House holding a sign that said "My Gay Children Deserve Rights."
The retired teacher said she traveled nine hours from Brevard, N.C., with dozens of others to represent children who were too busy working to make the trip. Of her four children, two are gay, she said.
"It's painful as a mother," she said. "It's discouraging. Every parent wants their children to have opportunities. But that's not what our government is about. I've seen nothing from the Obama administration."
Others seemed more hopeful.
"I love President Obama," said Kendra Bopp of Ashtabula, Ohio. "He's not perfect, but his heart's in the right place, and he's trying."
On Tuesday, David A. Catania (I-At Large), an openly gay member of the D.C. Council, introduced a bill that would allow same-sex marriages in the nation's capital. Council members have said they want to pass the measure by Christmas.
Maine is holding a referendum Nov. 3 that could overturn a state law approved in May that allows same-sex marriage. The vote is seen as a bellwether; five other states have legalized same-sex marriage, but none has done it with the affirmation of a popular vote.
Some District residents said they can taste victory.
Matthew Fornataro and William Dooner, a D.C. couple together for 3 1/2 years, said they want to get married as soon as the city will allow.
"Our country was founded on the idea all people are created equal," Fornataro said. "We as a country need to stand up for the ideals the founders based it on."
"D.C. is our nation's capital," said Jamie Stephens, who lives in the District. "If D.C. goes someplace, the rest of the nation is sure to follow. This is just a great steppingstone."
NOTE:
It is truly sad that traditional morality in the United States has deteriorated to the point where homosexuality is now widely considered a "right" i.e. gay "rights", a right to gay "marriage" etc. There can be no right to engage in practices which are contrary to the Natural (moral) Law. Homosexual activity is clearly incompatible with the Natural Law. Any "relationships" which result from such behaviors are illegitimate and destructive of the common good irrespective of what the individuals involved may think.
--Dr. J. P. Hubert
Washington Post Staff Writers
Monday, October 12, 2009

Tens of thousands of gay-rights activists marched Sunday in Washington to show President Obama and Congress that they are impatient with what they consider piecemeal progress and are ready to fight at the federal level for across-the-board equality, including for the right to marry and the right to serve in the military.
Key votes on same-sex marriage are coming up in the District and Maine, and Obama reiterated his campaign promise Saturday to end the "don't ask, don't tell" policy that forces gay and lesbian members of the armed forces to keep their sexual orientation a secret.
But organizers of the National Equality March and its participants said they want to shift the political effort toward seeking equality in all states, rather than accepting just local and state-level victories.
"We're not settling," said Cleve Jones, co-chairman of the march and founder of the Names Project, the AIDS memorial quilt that recognizes Americans who have died from HIV- or AIDS-related causes. "There's no such thing as a fraction of equality. We want equal protection under the law."
The march was coordinated by Equality Across America, a group formed this year. Organizers said they represent those who want immediate fundamental change in the legal status of gays, as opposed to those who think patience is needed as legal obstacles are overcome.
Some in the latter group are political veterans, such as Rep. Barney Frank (D-Mass.), the highest-ranking openly gay political figure in the United States. Last week, Frank said he thought the march was "useless," a remark that was attacked at the rally.
"How many more tears should be shed before some politicians in a backroom can decide it is convenient to join us and fight for our freedom?" asked David Mixner, a longtime activist who spoke at the rally.
Attendees expressed complicated feelings about Obama. Nearly every person interviewed said he or she had voted for him, but many people said they were disappointed by what they see as a lack of action on key gay-rights issues, such as letting gays serve openly in the military.
Thousands of people marched from McPherson Square, a few blocks from the White House, down Pennsylvania Avenue, chanting "President Obama: Let mama marry mama!" and "L, G, B, T -- We demand equality!"
Marchers carried signs reading "We Won't Wait for Full Equality" and "Mind Your Own Marriage." Spectators watched from the street and the roof of the Newseum, many cheering the participants. As the march ended about 2:30 p.m., people gathered on Capitol Hill for a rally.
Many supporters identified themselves as heterosexual, carrying signs with such slogans as "I'm Not Queer But I'm Here."
"They told me that you didn't care and you wouldn't come," Mixner told the crowd. "The president asked us to help him, and help him we will."
The march occurred at a critical time for the gay-rights movement, with a president who has vowed to fight for equality and Democrats in control of Congress.
Obama pledged Saturday night at a fundraising dinner for the Human Rights Campaign that he would end the military's "don't ask, don't tell" policy, but he provided no specifics on how. Many gay activists said that they are tired of waiting and that he should immediately move to repeal the military's policy and the Defense of Marriage Act.
Sue Null, 72, walked near the White House holding a sign that said "My Gay Children Deserve Rights."
The retired teacher said she traveled nine hours from Brevard, N.C., with dozens of others to represent children who were too busy working to make the trip. Of her four children, two are gay, she said.
"It's painful as a mother," she said. "It's discouraging. Every parent wants their children to have opportunities. But that's not what our government is about. I've seen nothing from the Obama administration."
Others seemed more hopeful.
"I love President Obama," said Kendra Bopp of Ashtabula, Ohio. "He's not perfect, but his heart's in the right place, and he's trying."
On Tuesday, David A. Catania (I-At Large), an openly gay member of the D.C. Council, introduced a bill that would allow same-sex marriages in the nation's capital. Council members have said they want to pass the measure by Christmas.
Maine is holding a referendum Nov. 3 that could overturn a state law approved in May that allows same-sex marriage. The vote is seen as a bellwether; five other states have legalized same-sex marriage, but none has done it with the affirmation of a popular vote.
Some District residents said they can taste victory.
Matthew Fornataro and William Dooner, a D.C. couple together for 3 1/2 years, said they want to get married as soon as the city will allow.
"Our country was founded on the idea all people are created equal," Fornataro said. "We as a country need to stand up for the ideals the founders based it on."
"D.C. is our nation's capital," said Jamie Stephens, who lives in the District. "If D.C. goes someplace, the rest of the nation is sure to follow. This is just a great steppingstone."
NOTE:
It is truly sad that traditional morality in the United States has deteriorated to the point where homosexuality is now widely considered a "right" i.e. gay "rights", a right to gay "marriage" etc. There can be no right to engage in practices which are contrary to the Natural (moral) Law. Homosexual activity is clearly incompatible with the Natural Law. Any "relationships" which result from such behaviors are illegitimate and destructive of the common good irrespective of what the individuals involved may think.
--Dr. J. P. Hubert
Thursday, September 3, 2009
The Death of Senator Kennedy: What Meaning for Catholics?
By: Dr. J. P. Hubert
The recent death of Senator Edward M. Kennedy of Massachusetts and its aftermath have been very instructive, especially for the world’s Roman Catholics, many of whom have become extremely confused by the response of several high-ranking U.S. prelates.[1] In the interest of fairness and complete candor, it is necessary to state clearly that Senator Kennedy was simultaneously a notorious and public denier of the Traditional Roman Catholic faith[2] and yet a defender at the same time of some of the Church’s most important teachings in the areas of Social Justice and Christian Charity.
In the days surrounding his demise, celebratory wake at the J. F. K Library and the funeral Mass at Boston’s Minor Basilica of Our Lady of Perpetual Help, (known as the Mission Church) nothing but laudatory comments were heard from friends, relatives, colleagues and the elite media. This is to be expected in that it is generally thought to be in extremely poor taste to criticize the dead, especially if the person in question has been a member in good standing of the elite secular regime as is the case with Senator Kennedy.
Regaled as the last remaining member of the true liberal left the so-called “Lion of the Senate”, Mr. Kennedy was celebrated for his tremendously prolific contribution to key Congressional legislation over his 47 year career and his laudable personal concern for and interest in the plight of minorities, immigrant communities, the poor and disabled in the United States. There is no question that Senator Kennedy advocated forcefully for the “least of those among us” especially in the areas of publicly financed health care for all Americans, public education and equal public access for persons with disabilities etc. The question however is--were these initiatives truly based on Roman Catholic teaching in the areas of Social Justice and Christian Charity or were they the logical outgrowth of liberal political policies which Senator Kennedy embraced throughout his career?
While Christian Charity and Social Justice are important parts of Traditional Roman Catholicism in practice, they do not make up the entire body of relevant Catholic teaching where issues of public policy are concerned. There exists an entire corpus of Traditional Catholic teaching which is applicable to issues of public policy specifically the moral responsibility of any legitimate government to uphold the Natural (moral) Law and to further the “common good.” On careful analysis, Senator Kennedy’s actions in the areas of Christian Charity and Social Justice seem to have been less relevant to his religious commitments then they were to his leadership of the liberal wing of the Democratic Party.
That his motivation was primarily political can be recognized in virtue of the fact that he was absolutely notorious in his rejection of Roman Catholic teaching in the areas of the sanctity of human life, the sanctity of (heterosexual) marriage, his support for abortion on demand including public financing of abortion and the particularly heinous partial birth abortion procedure, embryonic stem cell research, destructive human embryonic cloning for biomedical research, gay “rights” specifically same sex “marriage” and the codification in law of the “right” to engage in sodomy etc. All of these firmly held public policy positions were the very antithesis of a proper interpretation of the Natural Law and Traditional Roman Catholic teaching. The fact that Senator Kennedy despite claiming to be a Catholic in good standing could embrace these anti-Catholic views establishes beyond reasonable doubt to this writer that his fundamental underlying loyalty/predisposition was to political party and not to his self-professed religion.
Certainly, there was no one who so effectively championed the causes of the liberal left the way Senator Kennedy did. This was undoubtedly enhanced by his being highly motivated, and very likable and engaging on a personal level. For these attributes he should be celebrated by all true liberals. Many political moderates as well will also find much of Senator Kennedy’s legislative accomplishments to their liking such as the need in justice to provide a living wage and the necessity of providing frequent increases in the “cost of living” especially in benefit of the working poor.
On occasion even some conservatives could find themselves in agreement with the senator on issues such as the “no child left behind” legislation which he championed with former President George W. Bush and his life-long insistence that the United States should avoid wars of aggression[3]—a position which meant that he was virtually a “dove” throughout his entire career on the issue of war. Without doubt, this was an area where his secular political leanings coincided with the teachings of the Catholic Church with respect to the Just War Doctrine. However, since he rejected so much of Traditional Roman Catholic teaching, it is safe to say his consistent anti-war advocacy was also a function of his liberal political views rather than a foundational commitment to the Roman Catholic deposit of the faith.
The fact that Senator Kennedy appeared in some respects to be a good and faithful Traditional Catholic was extremely difficult to harmonize with his very forceful and public advocacy for positions which were contradictory of and antithetical to the faith. This no doubt bothered many Catholics and served as a way for non-Catholics to effectively ridicule the faith.[4] From the perspective of what is deducible on the basis of the public record, it is necessary to conclude that Senator Kennedy was not committed in any serious way to Traditional Catholicism—the faith of his mother Rose who he indicated was such an inspiration for him and his siblings. In the interest of upholding the dignity and reputation of Traditional Catholicism this is something which must simply be admitted lest it serve as the occasion of further scandal. This seemingly harsh judgment has nothing to do with the very public moral shortcomings of the Senator which assuming proper contrition, repentance and penance in combination with a public recanting of his un-Catholic views on social policy would have served as a magnificent testimony to the truth and power of the Catholic faith.
Unfortunately, we are left to wonder whether Senator Kennedy ever came to regret his tremendous influence and tireless work on behalf of so much evil and whether he confessed it sincerely in sacramental confession prior to his death—as seems to have been implied by the U.S. Catholic hierarchy—we can only hope and pray that he did. Rather however than serving as an occasion of clarification for the faithful, his death and burial have managed to further muddy the waters for serious Catholics who endeavor to understand the requirements of their faith and to live by them completely and consistently.
For a different view, see THIS...
NOTES:
1. Retired Theodore Cardinal Mc Carrick of Washington D.C. who officiated at the graveside ceremony at Arlington National Cemetery and the Cardinal Archbishop of Boston, Sean O’Malley who presided at the funeral Mass at the Mission Church through their very presence served to legitimate Senator Kennedy’s aberrant and decidedly anti-Traditional Catholic views on highly visible moral issues which have been truly infamous and a source of great scandal for the faithful.
2. His advocacy of abortion “rights”, embryonic stem cell research, human cloning for biomedical research, and same sex marriage laws etc. placed him clearly outside the Traditional Roman Catholic Church’s teaching. As far as the public record is concerned, he never repudiated the above policy positions. If he did so privately in sacramental confession prior to his death--something we are led to believe happened based on the statements of his private Priest and Cardinal O'Malley that he obtained salvation--it is particularly tragic for faithful Catholics who would have been so positively influenced by a public recantation.
3. Paleoconservatives such as Patrick J. Buchanan largely reject foreign wars of aggression even though Neoconservatives largely favor them. Neoconservatism however is an aberration. It is not really conservative in any meaningful sense and shares a lineage with Marxism.
4. Those who otherwise might have accepted the principled Catholic position were left to conclude that since someone as prominent in public life as Senator Kennedy did not subscribe to Catholic Church teaching on these issues, the church was not credible or it would have reprimanded him publicly.
The recent death of Senator Edward M. Kennedy of Massachusetts and its aftermath have been very instructive, especially for the world’s Roman Catholics, many of whom have become extremely confused by the response of several high-ranking U.S. prelates.[1] In the interest of fairness and complete candor, it is necessary to state clearly that Senator Kennedy was simultaneously a notorious and public denier of the Traditional Roman Catholic faith[2] and yet a defender at the same time of some of the Church’s most important teachings in the areas of Social Justice and Christian Charity.
In the days surrounding his demise, celebratory wake at the J. F. K Library and the funeral Mass at Boston’s Minor Basilica of Our Lady of Perpetual Help, (known as the Mission Church) nothing but laudatory comments were heard from friends, relatives, colleagues and the elite media. This is to be expected in that it is generally thought to be in extremely poor taste to criticize the dead, especially if the person in question has been a member in good standing of the elite secular regime as is the case with Senator Kennedy.
Regaled as the last remaining member of the true liberal left the so-called “Lion of the Senate”, Mr. Kennedy was celebrated for his tremendously prolific contribution to key Congressional legislation over his 47 year career and his laudable personal concern for and interest in the plight of minorities, immigrant communities, the poor and disabled in the United States. There is no question that Senator Kennedy advocated forcefully for the “least of those among us” especially in the areas of publicly financed health care for all Americans, public education and equal public access for persons with disabilities etc. The question however is--were these initiatives truly based on Roman Catholic teaching in the areas of Social Justice and Christian Charity or were they the logical outgrowth of liberal political policies which Senator Kennedy embraced throughout his career?
While Christian Charity and Social Justice are important parts of Traditional Roman Catholicism in practice, they do not make up the entire body of relevant Catholic teaching where issues of public policy are concerned. There exists an entire corpus of Traditional Catholic teaching which is applicable to issues of public policy specifically the moral responsibility of any legitimate government to uphold the Natural (moral) Law and to further the “common good.” On careful analysis, Senator Kennedy’s actions in the areas of Christian Charity and Social Justice seem to have been less relevant to his religious commitments then they were to his leadership of the liberal wing of the Democratic Party.
That his motivation was primarily political can be recognized in virtue of the fact that he was absolutely notorious in his rejection of Roman Catholic teaching in the areas of the sanctity of human life, the sanctity of (heterosexual) marriage, his support for abortion on demand including public financing of abortion and the particularly heinous partial birth abortion procedure, embryonic stem cell research, destructive human embryonic cloning for biomedical research, gay “rights” specifically same sex “marriage” and the codification in law of the “right” to engage in sodomy etc. All of these firmly held public policy positions were the very antithesis of a proper interpretation of the Natural Law and Traditional Roman Catholic teaching. The fact that Senator Kennedy despite claiming to be a Catholic in good standing could embrace these anti-Catholic views establishes beyond reasonable doubt to this writer that his fundamental underlying loyalty/predisposition was to political party and not to his self-professed religion.
Certainly, there was no one who so effectively championed the causes of the liberal left the way Senator Kennedy did. This was undoubtedly enhanced by his being highly motivated, and very likable and engaging on a personal level. For these attributes he should be celebrated by all true liberals. Many political moderates as well will also find much of Senator Kennedy’s legislative accomplishments to their liking such as the need in justice to provide a living wage and the necessity of providing frequent increases in the “cost of living” especially in benefit of the working poor.
On occasion even some conservatives could find themselves in agreement with the senator on issues such as the “no child left behind” legislation which he championed with former President George W. Bush and his life-long insistence that the United States should avoid wars of aggression[3]—a position which meant that he was virtually a “dove” throughout his entire career on the issue of war. Without doubt, this was an area where his secular political leanings coincided with the teachings of the Catholic Church with respect to the Just War Doctrine. However, since he rejected so much of Traditional Roman Catholic teaching, it is safe to say his consistent anti-war advocacy was also a function of his liberal political views rather than a foundational commitment to the Roman Catholic deposit of the faith.
The fact that Senator Kennedy appeared in some respects to be a good and faithful Traditional Catholic was extremely difficult to harmonize with his very forceful and public advocacy for positions which were contradictory of and antithetical to the faith. This no doubt bothered many Catholics and served as a way for non-Catholics to effectively ridicule the faith.[4] From the perspective of what is deducible on the basis of the public record, it is necessary to conclude that Senator Kennedy was not committed in any serious way to Traditional Catholicism—the faith of his mother Rose who he indicated was such an inspiration for him and his siblings. In the interest of upholding the dignity and reputation of Traditional Catholicism this is something which must simply be admitted lest it serve as the occasion of further scandal. This seemingly harsh judgment has nothing to do with the very public moral shortcomings of the Senator which assuming proper contrition, repentance and penance in combination with a public recanting of his un-Catholic views on social policy would have served as a magnificent testimony to the truth and power of the Catholic faith.
Unfortunately, we are left to wonder whether Senator Kennedy ever came to regret his tremendous influence and tireless work on behalf of so much evil and whether he confessed it sincerely in sacramental confession prior to his death—as seems to have been implied by the U.S. Catholic hierarchy—we can only hope and pray that he did. Rather however than serving as an occasion of clarification for the faithful, his death and burial have managed to further muddy the waters for serious Catholics who endeavor to understand the requirements of their faith and to live by them completely and consistently.
For a different view, see THIS...
NOTES:
1. Retired Theodore Cardinal Mc Carrick of Washington D.C. who officiated at the graveside ceremony at Arlington National Cemetery and the Cardinal Archbishop of Boston, Sean O’Malley who presided at the funeral Mass at the Mission Church through their very presence served to legitimate Senator Kennedy’s aberrant and decidedly anti-Traditional Catholic views on highly visible moral issues which have been truly infamous and a source of great scandal for the faithful.
2. His advocacy of abortion “rights”, embryonic stem cell research, human cloning for biomedical research, and same sex marriage laws etc. placed him clearly outside the Traditional Roman Catholic Church’s teaching. As far as the public record is concerned, he never repudiated the above policy positions. If he did so privately in sacramental confession prior to his death--something we are led to believe happened based on the statements of his private Priest and Cardinal O'Malley that he obtained salvation--it is particularly tragic for faithful Catholics who would have been so positively influenced by a public recantation.
3. Paleoconservatives such as Patrick J. Buchanan largely reject foreign wars of aggression even though Neoconservatives largely favor them. Neoconservatism however is an aberration. It is not really conservative in any meaningful sense and shares a lineage with Marxism.
4. Those who otherwise might have accepted the principled Catholic position were left to conclude that since someone as prominent in public life as Senator Kennedy did not subscribe to Catholic Church teaching on these issues, the church was not credible or it would have reprimanded him publicly.
Saturday, August 1, 2009
Momentum Builds for Homosexual (Gay) "Marriage"
Moral Anarchy Reins
By: Dr. J. P. Hubert
The momentum has now increased and the pendulum turned nation-wide in favor of homosexual "marriage." Civil Union's short of "marriage" while providing legal survivorship and other protections to same-sex couples have been seen as inadequate by homosexual activists who purport that the ability to marry is a civil right. By that they mean the right to marry whomever they wish--irrespective of the sex of the partners. This of course is a clear violation of the Natural (moral and biological) Law--as I have written elsewhere. While heterosexual simultaneous pleural marriage (bigamy or polygamy) however is not contrary to the natural law (biologically [and morally for several millennia prior to the ministry of Jesus Christ]), there is no hew and cry for the legalization of polygamy. Why? Presumably because bigamists in the US lack an effective lobby and or too few Americans prefer that arrangement--although many more might be interested in it if given the opportunity the way active homosexuals currently are.
The real question of course is to what extent is the ability to marry a civil right vs: a legally valid union in which the government preferentially (for practical reasons involving procreation, proper child-rearing etc.) favors traditional male/female coupling--theoretically for life--the traditional marriage arrangement?
If marriage is in fact a civil "right", then to remain intellectually consistent, the government must accept any arrangement an individual or group of persons wishes to codify as "marriage." That includes of course, polygamy, human/animal pairings and the like. Again if marriage is a "right" not a societal privilege, one can even question to what extent one person has the "right" to marry their child, sister, brother or even a minor provided the other party is willing. Once same-sex "marriage" is legalized, there is no logical way other than by a form of ad-hoc and completely arbitrary and capricious decision-making, to limit marriage to 2 human adults.
As can be seen here the legalization of same-sex "marriage" creates unresolvable philosophical and political problems which cannot be rectified by alterations in the law. Marriage (from a Natural Law and Christian moral perspective) should be limited to a life-long commitment between one man and one woman. Moreover, the fact that divorce is now available on-demand in the US adds to the difficulty of limiting marriage to heterosexual couples only. Widespread liberalization of state divorce laws in the mid 20th century (to the current on-demand status without the requirement of demonstrating adequate "grounds") no doubt prepared the way for the current same-sex "marriage" movement.
The great concern from the perspective of the common good should be that Traditional Marriage (TM) will become inherently weakened as an institution. If virtually any social arrangement among humans is legally to be considered marriage, (the clear direction that current momentum is taking) then what is unique or to be specially valued from a personal or societal standpoint with regard to TM? If males may legally marry males and females-females while both groups are increasingly able to adopt children what is there that is superior about a life-long heterosexual monogamous relationship that anyone should prefer it to any other arrangement including marital or non-marital infidelity? Will not many heterosexual couples simply avoid marriage altogether assuming that the entire concept has become vacuous/meaningless? If the sociological data establish that children benefit from stable heterosexual two parent families--and they do, what are we subjecting our children and grandchildren to while we carry out social experimentation on the institution of Traditional Marriage?
The entire same-sex "marriage" issue stems from an inability of post-modern man to recognize/accept the existence of "essences" that is, "natures" in the classical/scholastic sense. Post-moderns believe that man's basic "quiddity" or "whatness" is evolving and not fixed i.e. human anthropology is a work in progress. Of necessity then, morality is fluid, variable or relative to what the most politically powerful group(s) can inflict upon the majority from time to time. Such a scenario is the very definition of moral anarchy which very quickly devolves to a tyranny of the temporary majority.
By: Dr. J. P. Hubert
The momentum has now increased and the pendulum turned nation-wide in favor of homosexual "marriage." Civil Union's short of "marriage" while providing legal survivorship and other protections to same-sex couples have been seen as inadequate by homosexual activists who purport that the ability to marry is a civil right. By that they mean the right to marry whomever they wish--irrespective of the sex of the partners. This of course is a clear violation of the Natural (moral and biological) Law--as I have written elsewhere. While heterosexual simultaneous pleural marriage (bigamy or polygamy) however is not contrary to the natural law (biologically [and morally for several millennia prior to the ministry of Jesus Christ]), there is no hew and cry for the legalization of polygamy. Why? Presumably because bigamists in the US lack an effective lobby and or too few Americans prefer that arrangement--although many more might be interested in it if given the opportunity the way active homosexuals currently are.
The real question of course is to what extent is the ability to marry a civil right vs: a legally valid union in which the government preferentially (for practical reasons involving procreation, proper child-rearing etc.) favors traditional male/female coupling--theoretically for life--the traditional marriage arrangement?
If marriage is in fact a civil "right", then to remain intellectually consistent, the government must accept any arrangement an individual or group of persons wishes to codify as "marriage." That includes of course, polygamy, human/animal pairings and the like. Again if marriage is a "right" not a societal privilege, one can even question to what extent one person has the "right" to marry their child, sister, brother or even a minor provided the other party is willing. Once same-sex "marriage" is legalized, there is no logical way other than by a form of ad-hoc and completely arbitrary and capricious decision-making, to limit marriage to 2 human adults.
As can be seen here the legalization of same-sex "marriage" creates unresolvable philosophical and political problems which cannot be rectified by alterations in the law. Marriage (from a Natural Law and Christian moral perspective) should be limited to a life-long commitment between one man and one woman. Moreover, the fact that divorce is now available on-demand in the US adds to the difficulty of limiting marriage to heterosexual couples only. Widespread liberalization of state divorce laws in the mid 20th century (to the current on-demand status without the requirement of demonstrating adequate "grounds") no doubt prepared the way for the current same-sex "marriage" movement.
The great concern from the perspective of the common good should be that Traditional Marriage (TM) will become inherently weakened as an institution. If virtually any social arrangement among humans is legally to be considered marriage, (the clear direction that current momentum is taking) then what is unique or to be specially valued from a personal or societal standpoint with regard to TM? If males may legally marry males and females-females while both groups are increasingly able to adopt children what is there that is superior about a life-long heterosexual monogamous relationship that anyone should prefer it to any other arrangement including marital or non-marital infidelity? Will not many heterosexual couples simply avoid marriage altogether assuming that the entire concept has become vacuous/meaningless? If the sociological data establish that children benefit from stable heterosexual two parent families--and they do, what are we subjecting our children and grandchildren to while we carry out social experimentation on the institution of Traditional Marriage?
The entire same-sex "marriage" issue stems from an inability of post-modern man to recognize/accept the existence of "essences" that is, "natures" in the classical/scholastic sense. Post-moderns believe that man's basic "quiddity" or "whatness" is evolving and not fixed i.e. human anthropology is a work in progress. Of necessity then, morality is fluid, variable or relative to what the most politically powerful group(s) can inflict upon the majority from time to time. Such a scenario is the very definition of moral anarchy which very quickly devolves to a tyranny of the temporary majority.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)